Showing posts with label LHaley. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LHaley. Show all posts

Friday, 5 January 2024

Using board games to increase inclusion in research - a trivial pursuit?

Posted by Lesley Haley, AskFuse Research Associate, Teesside University 

Did you play any board games over the holidays? As we scrabble into 2024, have you ever thought about how they could be used as a way to engage people in your research?

I hadn’t, until I went to a recent Creative Methods in Research conference, where Kath Maguire (University of Exeter/NIHR School for Public Health Research) showcased how using board games in research was anything but trivial! Kath demonstrated the concept of using board games in public involvement and engagement can increase participation by reaching people less comfortable with standard formats of engagement or data collection, such as interviews or questionnaires.

Kath brought examples, like a “pairs” game used with public partners to break down barriers of understanding around the jargon used in research. Pairing research jargon, concepts or acronyms (‘randomised control’, ‘double blinded’, ‘SPHR’, ‘NIHR’ for example) with their plain English explanations allowed all participants to probe the underlying assumptions and constructs, and perhaps to reduce the power imbalance between the knowledge giver (usually researchers) with the knowledge receiver (usually public partners). And of course this game can be used to redress that balance by public partners sharing their knowledge with researchers.

However, the most surprising game that Kath has used in increasing involvement was the repurposing of that classic multicultural game, Snakes and Ladders.

While AskFuse (the responsive research and evaluation service run by Fuse) created the pictured Snakes and Ladders game as an interactive way to explore successes (Ladders) and setbacks (Snakes) of getting research knowledge used in practice, Kath has taken the game to a whole new level.

Kath has a wealth of experience in using board games as a creative method of inclusion to reach people less comfortable with more literacy-based research methods. They bring a blank paper board and a variety of stick-on snakes and ladders as a visual prompt to generate discussion and reflection using the metaphor of the game to explore a range of experiences. The aim is not necessarily to play the game, but to use the building of a bespoke “game” to reflect and “illustrate” narratives and experiences.

Participating in Kath’s interactive workshop was, for me, a real game changer. We explored how using snakes and ladders enabled discussion, reflection and inclusion. We could design our own individual game to tell our story, or do it collaboratively. We used the game layout as a metaphor for exploring changes through time or to illustrate a “journey” (for example, exploring access or barriers to health services). It allowed us to describe and reflect on different pathways or starting points. Being a physical representation of our narrative meant that, at times, “gaps” emerged which led to questions around “what was happening here?” and “what are we missing?” The grid could also used to reflect emotional journeys in response to a given (research) question or situation. We explored how focussing on a game allowed for different viewpoints to emerge and for less vocally confident people to engage without having to “carry” a conversation or justify their experience. The game squares could be filled with comments, contributing factors, and ideas. We reflected that the snakes and ladders could be reconfigured for creative re-imagining of time/place/situations - “what would happen if we did this”? And of course the complexities of the research process can be illustrated through the metaphor of Snakes and Ladders.

At the end of the session, there was a tangible product and graphic representation of the research question, the process and the outcomes of the exploration. We reflected that over several sessions, the game would perhaps change and this progress could be captured in photos. The “game” could also then be used creatively to disseminate the research (Coon et al 2022).

We also explored the risk that a gaming method for engagement or data collection, especially in the “Snakes & Ladders” format, could be seen by some people as trivialising the serious business of research, as in the UK it is perceived as a child’s game. However the game is not all it appears. Originally known in “Moksha Patamu”, it was a philosophical game of actions and consequences for adults developed in ancient India (Museum of Gaming 2015). Over time and locality, the game has evolved into other versions, with snakes transformed into “drainpipes” or “chutes (Start the Week 2023). So the game has a tradition of being adapted and re-purposed and perhaps we should not be shy of re-purposing it to make research more accessible?

Since Kath’s workshop, I’ve had a quick look around to see if there are other researchers using gaming. While there is literature on using board games in health education and promotion (Nakao 2019) and public health policy (Spitters 2018) there seems less on the use of board games in public involvement and engagement in health.

Of course, snakes and ladders doesn’t have the monopoly on being the only board game that can be used. So, do you use board games in your research to engage with people and communities? What's been your experience of what works for who? How do you pitch it? What have you found the setbacks and successes of using board games as a creative way of engaging people and communities?

As you scrabble to fit all the board games back into the cupboard after Christmas, maybe it’s time to reflect that participatory board games in research could be for the rest of the year too, not just for Christmas.

With thanks to Kath Maguire for the interactive workshop and to SPHR for funding attendance at the conference.




References:

Coon, J.T., Orr, N., Shaw, L. et al. (2022) Bursting out of our bubble: using creative techniques to communicate within the systematic review process and beyond. Syst Rev 11, 56 https://systematicreviewsjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s13643-022-01935-2

Kath’s work:

Museum of Gaming Newsletter (2015) Issue 2 Snakes and Ladders History. Accessed 2 Jan 2024 Available at: https://www.museumofgaming.org.uk/documents/Newsletter2.pdf https://www.museumofgaming.org.uk/index.cfm

Nakao M (2019) Effects of board games on health education and promotion” board games as a promising tool for health promotion: a review of recent literature BioPsychoSocial Medicine (2019) 13:5 https://doi.org/10.1186/s13030-019-0146-3

Spitters H.P.E.M , van de Goor L.A.M, Juel Lau C, Sandu P , Eklund Karlsson L , Jansen J, van Oers J.A.M (2018) Learning from games: stakeholders’ experiences involved in local health policy Journal of Public Health | Vol. 40, Supplement 1, pp. i39–i49 | doi:10.1093/pubmed/fdx149 https://academic.oup.com/jpubhealth/article/40/suppl_1/i39/4925598

Start the Week: Playing Games (2023) BBC Radio 4 Monday 4th December 2023 09.00 Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001t2xq?partner=uk.co.bbc&origin=share-mobile (Accessed 8 Dec 2023)

Friday, 1 December 2023

Getting creative to make research more accessible and inclusive

Posted by Victoria Bartle, Fuse Public Partner

We were throwing balls of wool around, picking picture cards to describe ourselves and having a thoroughly inspiring time. This was not your typical research conference!

It was day one and keynote speaker Pam Burnard was encouraging us to challenge the system using creative methods to subvert common assumptions.

Many of the researchers at the International Creative Research Methods Conference in Manchester are independent, not linked to a specific university or funder and this allows them to approach research from a variety of unusual and unfamiliar angles.

The conference is the brainchild of Dr Helen Kara: independent researcher, author, teacher, speaker and creative research methods (CRM) expert. Helen’s vision was to bring together the global CRM community to share knowledge, promote understanding, enable networking and have fun!

After the first day's keynote, I went to see Nicole Brown, a researcher looking at fibromyalgia, a condition that I also have. She had asked people living with fibromyalgia to collect objects to describe how the condition made them feel. One person had taken a photo of her chair - a really comfortable armchair, with a blanket, a table beside it holding drinks, snacks and distractions. This could have been a picture of my own living room! Due to chronic pain and fatigue I have what I call my 'nest'. I have reclining sofas with a side table with all of my remotes, chargers, creams, spare meds, thermostat, drinks, snacks, book, switch, lip balm (etc.) just so that everything I need is within reach and I don’t have to move too much or cause myself too much pain. I found the picture really impactful and saw the potential for objects, artwork and abstract thinking to be able to describe conditions like fibromyalgia which is extremely difficult to explain to someone who doesn’t have it. Using objects as data to assess and evaluate was really interesting and a methodology that I wasn’t previously aware of.

We were then given the task of picking some cards to describe ourselves as researchers.

These are the lego cards I chose to describe me during the sessions by Nicole Brown, who works with objects as data in research.

The skydiver because I feel like I just ask to do things and hope for the best, the singer because I like to present and talk about PPI (Patient and Public Involvement) in research. 

Black widow because she’s a superhero and fights for people who can’t and Rocket because he’s been made up with tech and I felt like he’s a disabled superhero :)



Jargon buzzing

On day 2 the Lawnmowers Theatre Company, run by and for people with learning difficulties, brought out jargon buzzers which were amazing! The characters pressed the buzzers every time someone used a term or word that they didn’t understand. I really want to use these in PPI meetings in the future, but we might not get anything done having to explain all the acronyms and research language that is often used!

Making a 'zine'

I didn’t know anything about zines and wasn’t aware of the Madzine project to help people with mental health conditions to explain how they feel, get things out and be creative. The session was really interesting giving us some history on zines before we were able to create our own. I made one about a project that I have been working on using some paper with stars on to represent the PPI Group members. A black page for accessibility as we all had different barriers to involvement and some of them were difficult to address, hidden or unknown. Some of the zines that they showed us were amazing: creative, visual, unusual, thought provoking and touching. They plan to create a mobile Madzine library that tours around the country so that people can read the zines and share in the experiences of the creators to increase awareness and understanding of living with mental health conditions.

Board games, rockpools and podcasts  

Kath McGuire (University of Exeter/NIHR School for Public Health Research), led our session talking about working with creative methods, public involvement and research dissemination. I briefly introduced the Fuse podcast and explained the collaborative approach to creating it. People were then able to take a look around the room at the variety of creative outputs that we had brought with us, and a video about how we have creatively communicated research in Fuse (see below). We had a snakes and ladders game to be used with PPI groups, or groups of researchers to evaluate their projects: snakes were barriers and challenges and ladders were successes and wins. We also took posters created by Fuse researchers showing their project results (Emma Adams) and Kath had a Blue Health Rockpool from another project. We took questions and explained how we created the podcast, what its impact had been and answered lots of technical questions about equipment, hosting and distribution. Hopefully accurately!


Attending the conference really broadened my view of research and public involvement. Lots of researchers at the conference felt that by making their work more creative it made it more inclusive. By reducing or removing established barriers to involvement such as language, terminology, education level and academic preconceptions they were able to engage with a wider, more diverse group of people. They could still be academically rigorous and produce research that stands up to peer review and meets publication standards whilst including more people, accessing people with appropriate lived experience of their topic of study and making involvement engaging, interesting and fun!

I have come away from the conference wanting to make Patient and Public Involvement meetings more creative, use games and objects to describe feelings and opinions, implement the jargon buzzer and design engaging dissemination methods that are relevant to the target audience of the study, drawing on the skills of the researchers and PPI teams.

A special thanks to Kath Maguire, Daniel Mutanda and Heather Boult (University of Exeter/NIHR School for Public Health Research), and the Fuse colleagues: Lesley Haley, who helped me with the podcast aspect of the workshop 'market place'; Ella Anderson for preparing the workshop activity; and Mark Welford for producing the Creatively communicating research video that we used in the session.

Friday, 22 May 2020

Covid-19 and the legacy of Edward Jenner: a tale of two pathogens

Posted by Lesley Haley, AskFuse Research Associate, Teesside University 

2020 is going to be a momentous year in world history as the year that the Covid-19 pandemic changed all our lives.

Edward Jenner, English physician who discovered the smallpox vaccine
Coincidentally, this year also marks the 40th anniversary of a significant historic milestone for another deadly disease, but in this case, one which maimed, killed and shaped global history for the past three thousand years (Flight 2011). That disease was smallpox.

On the surface, there is nothing in common between a dead disease and a newly emerging one. But there are some aspects of the history of smallpox that resonate with the unfolding story of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Smallpox was still a killer when I was vaccinated against it in 1967 as part of a routine public health intervention, although it was no longer endemic in the UK. For my mother’s generation, the reality of smallpox was very stark. She experienced the panic of an outbreak in her home town of Glasgow during the war when she was only 10, and again when she was 16, when smallpox killed front-line staff treating infected patients at the local hospital.

Although in 1967 outbreaks in the UK of smallpox were getting rarer, the worldwide picture was very different. Smallpox was still endemic in many countries, maiming and killing an estimated 10-15 million people a year (Baxby 1999). This was despite the fact that Edward Jenner had first introduced a prototype inoculation against smallpox in 1798, had translated his theories and ideas into practice, and had a huge impact during his lifetime (the academic dream!).

One aspect of Jenner’s life and work bears closer scrutiny in light of the current Covid-19 pandemic, and particularly on the emerging debate surrounding the development of a new vaccine. During his lifetime, Jenner made his research, his ideas and his smallpox inoculations freely available to everyone, irrespective of who they were (Baxby 1999). Jenner and his contemporaries appreciated the commercial opportunities of his discovery, but he continued to give free inoculations to everyone who approached him at his surgery, despite the detrimental financial impact this had on his personal and professional life (Britannica 2020). He understood exactly what the implications of his discovery meant for the common good.

So if Jenner’s work was freely available, (and although certainly not perfect), why was smallpox still endemic in some countries in the world in 1967? Millward (2019) proposed that one of the main issues had been the lack of global “joined up thinking” in the approach towards smallpox eradication. It took until 1967 for countries where smallpox was not endemic to realise that they would always be at risk of continual and increasing numbers of smallpox outbreaks, if the disease was still endemic in other parts of the world. Wherever in the world there was smallpox outbreaks, it caused mass panic, strained public health systems to the limit, maimed and killed, and even had economic impacts on national and international trade and travel (Millward 2019). It therefore became in every countries' interest to support a systematic, unified and global approach to smallpox eradication. Under the auspices of the World Health Organisation (WHO), the global strategy of surveillance, containment and vaccination free at the point of delivery and irrespective of ability to pay, worked. In 1980, the WHO declared the world free from smallpox (Baxby 1999) and it became the “first disease to be controlled by immunisation, the first to be eradicated” (Baxby 1999).

So what will historians say about the story of Covid-19? What will be the role of the global community in tackling the Covid-19 pandemic? Will Jenner’s altruistic example of free and accessible vaccinations be consigned to the history books in the 2020 global race to develop a lifesaving Covid-19 vaccine?

On the global front, 4 May 2020 saw world leaders, the UN, research institutions and philanthropic organisations pledge resources to find a vaccine for Covid-19 (albeit with the ominous absence of two major world powers) (BBC 2020). And the race for a vaccine has sparked debates on who, where, and how people would access a Covid-19 vaccine, with speculation for example, that pharmaceutical companies may have to change their business practices (Chu 2020). In the history of smallpox in the UK, vaccine stockpiles were held by private businesses, highlighting “that public health resources were not always in public hands” (Millward 2019, p. 64).

Global businesses have also contributed to an “Open Covid Pledge, “to make intellectual property available free of charge for use in ending Covid-19 pandemic and minimising the impact of the disease” (Open Covid Pledge 2020).

When global powers pulled together for the common good, it took just 13 years to rid the world of a disease that had killed millions across the continents of Africa, America, Australia, Asia and Europe in its 3000 year reign of terror. Prior to that, without global unity and treatment free at the point of delivery, it took 169 years. I wonder what Edward Jenner would have thought?

So as our Covid-19 story unfolds in 2020 and beyond, I wonder how future generations will judge the actions and decisions of our current global leaders and businesses?



References:
  1. Flight, C (2011) Smallpox : Eradicating the scourge. BBC History. Last updated 17 Feb 2011. Available: https://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/empire_seapower/smallpox_01.shtml Accessed: 05 May 2020.
  2. Baxby, D (1999) The End of Smallpox. History Today Vol 49 Issue 3. Available: https://www.historytoday.com/archive/end-smallpox
  3. Britannica (2020) Edward Jenner. Available: https://www.britannica.com/biography/Edward-Jenner Accessed: 6 May 2020. 
  4. Millward G (2019) “Smallpox” Vaccinating Britain: Mass vaccination and the public since the Second World War, Chapter 2. [Internet]. Manchester (UK): Manchester University Press; 2019. Chapter 2. Available: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK545998/#!po=98.8688 Accessed: 5 May 2020. 
  5. BBC News (2020) Coronavirus: World Leaders pledge billions for vaccine fight. Available: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-52525387 Accessed: 5 May 2020. 
  6. Chu, B(2020) “To find a vaccine for coronavirus, pharmaceutical companies will have to Adamson the race for profit”. The Independent. Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/coronavirus-vaccine-uk-pharmaceutical-companies-patent-monopoly-a9467381.html Accessed: 16 April 2020. 
  7. The Open Covid Pledge (2020) Available: https://opencovidpledge.org. Accessed: 5 May 2020. 

Acknowledgements:
  • Mrs Patricia Hoyland (pers comm)
  • BBC Today programme. Thought for the day. David Wilkinson 4 May 2020.

Image: 
  1. “Edwar Jenner” by Pan American Health Organization PAHO via Flickr.com, copyright © 2010: https://www.flickr.com/photos/pahowho/9525240640. Attribution-NoDerivs 2.0 Generic (CC BY-ND 2.0)
  2. The logo of Open COVID Pledge project, 27 August 2020. Creative Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0>, via Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Open_Covid_Pledge_Logo.jpg).

Thursday, 11 October 2018

Safe negotiation of neighbourhoods should be non-negotiable

Posted by Lesley Haley, AskFuse Research Associate, Teesside University

It’s World Sight Day today. This annual event highlights a range of issues surrounding visual impairment, and the day is linked to the World Health Organisation’s Global Action Plan on sight health. Today is also ‘bin collection day’ where I live, when wheelie bins and recycling boxes migrate from their backyards and gardens to clutter our pavements. It’s a weekly event that occurs in every village, town and city. It’s also a weekly hazard to be negotiated and endured by thousands of our neighbours. Especially those with visual impairment.





It’s not an obvious connection - World Sight Day and ‘bin day’. And frankly it was a connection that didn’t occur to me either, until I went to the ‘Negotiating Neighbourhoods’ event earlier this year, run by Fuse, the Royal National Institute for the Blind (RNIB), and the Sight Service. The event examined getting around our neighbourhoods, and gave feedback on Newcastle City Council/RNIB’s Newcastle Street Charter. The Charter describes the barriers faced by people with sight loss or mobility issues, and the actions and commitments needed and agreed to reduce these barriers (Newcastle City Council 2017). At the event, policy makers, researchers and people who are experts by experience shared their opinions and insights into safely getting around the built environment of our streets, local neighbourhoods and public spaces. This included feedback on the proliferation of street furniture such as advertising boards, lamp posts, bollards, street signs, bushes, cars parked on pavements, and wheelie bins (Newcastle City Council 2017).

Sight loss affected more than two million people in the UK in 2015, with one in five people aged over 75 living with some form of sight loss, including macular degeneration (RNIB 2018c). So for a significant number of our neighbours with mobility or sight issues, street ‘clutter’ is an increasingly frustrating and problematic issue.

It’s a public health issue too. Street furniture is impacting the health and wellbeing of people with mobility or sight loss issues. The built environment, and the street furniture cluttering it, “is restricting physical activity participation for people with sight loss” (Phoenix et al, 2015, p.127). Sight loss is associated with reduced physical activity, and the adverse social, economic and psychological effects of sight loss are being more widely recognised, including loneliness and isolation (Sim and Mackie 2015). Even the Design Council (2017) reported that ‘hostile’ public spaces could increase people’s risk of disease as it contributed to sedentary lifestyles and social isolation.

Can the humble wheelie bin really be classed as ‘hostile’? The experts by experience at the ‘Negotiating Neighbourhoods’ event have bitter experiences to prove it. Research in public health would also back them up. In 2015, 95 per cent of blind and partially sighted people reported that, in the previous three months, they had collided with a street obstacle, and a third said they had injured themselves while walking around their local area (RNIB 2015a). Many participants in the research carried out by Phoenix et al (2015) talked about injuries and also damage to their self-esteem when outdoors, because of a poorly designed built environment. Street ‘clutter’ is literally having a big impact on our neighbours as they try to navigate our streets.

At the ‘Negotiating Neighbourhoods’ event, the audience was asked “What changes could make the situation better?” Well, from a personal perspective, I have tried to stop parking my car on the pavement, have changed where I place my wheelie bin on ‘bin day’, and have tried to write (this) my first ever blog to raise awareness of the issue.

So what are your thoughts? Could you make one small change in your neighbourhood to make everybody’s everyday journeys just a little bit safer?

Surely, on World Sight day in 2018, being able to safely negotiate our neighbourhoods, should not be negotiable?

#WorldSightDay


References:

Design Council (2017) Creating Health Places Available at: https://www.designcouncil.org.uk/what-we-do/built-environment/creating-healthy-places (Accessed: 23.08.2018).

Newcastle City Council (2017) Newcastle Street Charter. Newcastle: Newcastle City Council. Available at: https://www.newcastle.gov.uk/sites/default/files/wwwfileroot/your-council-and-democracy/equality-diversity-and-citizenship/newcastle_street_charter_final.pdf (Accessed on: 23.08.2018)

Phoenix, C. Griffin, M. Smith, B. (2015) ‘Physical activity among older people with sight loss: a qualitative research study to inform policy and practice environment,’ Public Health 129 (2) pp. 124-130

Royal National Institute of Blind People (RNIB) (2015a): Daily assault course of street obstacles and dangerous crossings injuring blind people. Available at: http://www.rnib.org.uk/daily-assault-course-street-obstacles-and-dangerous-crossings-injuring-blind-people. (Accessed 26.04.2018)

Royal National Institute of Blind People (2018c) Key information and statistics on sight loss in the UK. Available at: https://www.rnib.org.uk/professionals/knowledge-and-research-hub/key-information-and-statistics (Accessed: 01.06.2018).

Sim F, and Mackie, P (2015) ‘Sight – the most critical sense for public health?’ Public Health. 129 (2) pp. 89–90. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.puhe.2015.01.009. (Accessed: 22/08/2018)

World Health Organisation (2009) Global Action Plan for the Prevention of Avoidable Blindness and Visual Impairment 2009-2013. Available at: https://www.iapb.org/resources/who-action-plan-for-the-prevention-of-avoidable-blindness-and-visual-impairment-2009-2013/ (Accessed: 23.8.2018)