Showing posts with label sustainability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sustainability. Show all posts

Friday, 21 August 2026

Training tomorrow’s Public Health leaders: impact, innovation and prevention

Posted by Liz Morgan, Head of School for Public Health North East, NHS England

The North East Public Health Postgraduate Specialty Training Programme holds an event annually to showcase the work that has been done by trainees over the previous year. This annual showcase highlights how public health trainees in the North East are delivering practical, high‑impact work across the health and care system, demonstrating the value of prevention-led leadership at a time of increasing system pressure. It not only celebrates the tremendous work our trainees have been doing but also provides an opportunity to share that work with public health colleagues in multiple settings During this time, our trainees will have been immersed in communities, health and health-related systems and research environments, identifying challenges, designing solutions and implementing projects that demonstrate innovation and impact. The projects presented at our last meeting ranged from heath protection and health improvement to policy development and healthcare public health. Each one reflected the commitment, curiosity and compassion that defines our public health workforce.


Tackling air pollution through NHS leadership


Most NHS Trusts in the North East employ at least one public health consultant, valuing the broad benefits that this can bring, but also providing greater capacity for public health training. Dr Laura Keast had been undertaking a placement in Northumbria NHS Trust, implementing the Clean Air Hospital Framework and demonstrated the value of collaboration between public health and sustainability teams. Air pollution remains the single greatest environmental threat to public health in the UK, contributing to an estimated 30,000 deaths annually and worsening health inequalities. By making air pollution a tangible and locally relevant issue through accessible monitoring of nitrogen dioxide levels and clear health messaging, the initiative has generated engagement and momentum for action. Importantly, the project highlighted that public health leadership, data expertise, powerful health messaging and alignment with national policy levers are critical in overcoming uncertainty and organisational resistance to change.

Reducing missed outpatient appointments for children

Dr Mark Riley presented a service evaluation undertaken at South Tees NHS Trust exploring why children are not brought to outpatient appointments, an issue with significant implications for health outcomes and system efficiency. Using surveys and follow-up telephone calls, the evaluation identified five key themes:
  • appointment timing
  • forgotten appointments and reminders
  • administrative barriers
  • health literacy
  • cost of attendance.
Forgotten appointments were the most common reason for non-attendance, with parents strongly favouring clearer and more frequent text reminders. Difficulties rearranging appointments, confusing letters and limited awareness of travel cost reimbursement schemes further contributed to missed care. The findings underscore how relatively small, system-level changes, such as health-literate communications in multiple languages and flexible appointment scheduling to include evenings, can reduce inequalities and improve service use. Finding a champion in the organisation to enable change was also critical.

How leaders make difficult priority-setting decisions

As pressures on the NHS intensify, difficult decisions about how to allocate limited resources are unavoidable. Dr Tom Seasman explored how senior health leaders justified priority-setting decisions. Qualitative in‑depth interviews with leaders across the English health system show broad support for prevention and reducing health inequalities. However, when faced with real-world trade-offs, decisions often favour short-term frontline clinical care over long-term preventative investment and leaders differ in their responses. Clinical leaders often prioritise immediate need and the “rule of rescue”, while those approaching the same problem from a public health perspective place greater emphasis on maximising population health gains through prevention. Political constraints, emotional proximity to patients and fragmented funding structures frequently limit leaders’ ability to shift resources from acute care to prevention, despite widespread recognition that long-term sustainability depends on doing so. These findings raise important questions about how the health system can better support leaders to make transparent and ethical trade-offs.

Policing and public health: prevention in action

Prevention also featured strongly in work exploring collaboration between policing and public health. This is important because of shared commitments to improve lives, reduce harm, reduce unnecessary demand on services, reduce vulnerability, improve equity and maintain public trust. Since the publication of a national consensus statement in 2018, prevention has become more explicitly embedded within policing policy and inspection frameworks. A 2025 review concluded that, while the original vision remained relevant, a refreshed consensus was needed to reflect current challenges and language. Kylie Murrell led on this national project, chairing the policing and public health collaborative, leading on the re-drafting of the document and sign off and associated ministerial briefing. The work highlights both the appetite within policing to engage more fully in prevention and the ongoing need for public health professionals to support cross-sector partners to identify upstream opportunities to reduce harm, vulnerability and demand. It's also an excellent example of how our trainees have led on national initiatives.

Supporting wellbeing within the public health workforce

Alongside the ongoing system-level challenges, attention to the wellbeing of the public health workforce itself is increasingly recognised as essential. Vineeta O’Key reflected on the work the trainees had been doing to support their own wellbeing and on how a Wellbeing Away Day could demonstrate how evidence-based wellbeing approaches could be embedded within training and professional development. Grounded in the “Five Ways to Wellbeing”, the day prioritised connection, learning, physical activity and engagement with nature through volunteering with Durham Wildlife Trust. Feedback highlighted the value of protected time for relationship-building, reflection and compassionate leadership, reinforcing the role of wellbeing as both a personal and professional competency in public health practice.

Julie Lowe presented her experience of travelling to Canada and the Netherlands on a Churchill Foundation fellowship. The Foundation funds approximately 100 Fellows each year to travel overseas to explore an issue of societal importance. This project focused on community interventions to improve the health and wellbeing of unpaid caregivers, who, as a population, experience poorer mental and physical health outcomes known informally as the ‘carer burden’. She shared reflections from her own experience as a young carer and motivation for choosing a career in public health. Findings from her experience included the importance of listening to diverse groups of carers to understand their needs and preferences, and the need for interventions that reduce carer burden rather than responding to health needs as they arise.

Taken together, these projects reflect a common theme: public health impact is maximised through leadership, collaboration and a commitment to prevention, even in constrained systems. Our trainees are already having an impact in their placements and communities by shaping national priorities, supporting workforce wellbeing and building partnerships beyond health. Creating spaces like this conference where recent projects and ideas can be shared, and challenges are explored are vital and demonstrates how public health continues to be pivotal in navigating complexity and working towards more equitable and sustainable futures. I would strongly encourage all of our public educators and senior public health colleagues to attend this event. As Public Health influencers, the task of considering, adapting and altering these ideas and interventions for the benefit of the populations we serve rests with us.

Tuesday, 31 May 2022

Are we really aware of the harm Big Tobacco causes our planet?

Posted by Ailsa Rutter OBE, Director of Fresh and Balance on World No Tobacco Day

The annual World Health Organization (WHO) campaign highlights the many harms of tobacco. This year’s theme explores the growing threat to our environment.





We know that smoking is the worst thing that we can do for our health – 8 million people around the world lose their lives from it each year.

Many of us are already taking action to do our bit in tackling climate change. But do we ever think about how tobacco is polluting our world globally, nationally and here in North East England?

As we face a climate emergency, our fragile ecosystems are being put under even more pressure by the tobacco industry. Tobacco damages the environment, from growing and production, distribution to waste.

Reflecting on my 24 plus years in tobacco control, I’ve seen many appalling tactics from Big Tobacco (the largest global tobacco companies who make billions in profit from killing people and destroying the planet) – including ploys to get kids hooked on a life-long addiction.

It takes a lot to shock me these days, but even I am shocked to read the things that the tobacco industry is doing to our environment.

What we see on the surface is just the tip of the iceberg. Some of the mind-blowing statistics every year:
  • 600 million trees chopped down for tobacco.
  • 84 million tonnes of C02 released into the air, raising global temperatures.
  • 22 billion tonnes of water used to make cigarettes.
  • 4.5 trillion cigarette butts not disposed of properly across the globe, generating 1.69 billion pounds of toxic waste and releasing thousands of chemicals into the environment.
Big Tobacco ‘greenwashes’ its impact on the environment through sustainability corporate social responsibility and marketing initiatives, designed to make people and investors think it cares.

Every day we see its impact on our streets and beaches. Cigarettes are the most commonly littered item in the world.

Cigarette butts are made of cellulose acetate, a man-made plastic material, which takes years to degrade and dump a toxic mix of nicotine, arsenic and heavy metals into our water, soil and oceans before turning into microplastic pollution. It makes me so sad to think what this toxic waste is doing to our marine and river wildlife.

Eight out of 10 (81%) North Easterners in a YouGov poll commissioned by Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) want to see plastic in cigarette butts banned. As part of our World No Tobacco Day activity, we’re joining forces with environmental campaigners to protect the region’s beaches from plastic cigarette butts.

Beyond our region, in the developing world, deforestation for tobacco plantations is happening on a vast scale. Around 3.5 million hectares of land are destroyed for tobacco growing each year. That’s the equivalent of over 1.4 million football fields!

The environmental burden is falling on the countries which are the least able to cope with it. Farmers in low- and middle-income countries are left in debt, with widespread poverty and illness among farm workers. Meanwhile the global tobacco companies continue to make billions in profit.

I reflect on when I attended a world conference in 2006 and heard about young children being exploited for child labour by tobacco companies; picking tobacco leaves and exposed to toxic pesticides and hazardous working conditions. The consequences are life-long and this is happening around the world, as shown in the devastating 2016 Human Right Watch report “Harvest is in my Blood”.

As a mother, with children and grandchildren, I am extremely concerned about the future impact.

The question I think we should ask ourselves is – are we really aware of the harm that the tobacco industry is causing to the environment? If the answer is no, then let’s pledge to read some of the fantastic resources on the issue, including those on the WHO website. Talk to people about it, call for action. Learn more about the tobacco industry; the harm it causes.

 

We are supporting national colleagues Action on Smoking and Health in calling for a levy on Big Tobacco, to clean up the harm and to further reduce smoking to reach the Government’s target of a Smokefree 2030 (5% by 2030).

In the North East we’ve seen smoking rates fall faster than anywhere else in the country, thanks to the hard work and dedication of colleagues in the region.

But as the major threat of climate change looms, it’s vital that we go further and faster than ever to reduce the tobacco industry’s destructive impact and make smoking history for the next generation.



Ailsa Rutter OBE, is Director of Fresh and Balance, the North East’s combined alcohol and tobacco programme, working to reduce the harm, the death and disease caused by smoking and alcohol.

Tobacco is still the biggest cause of premature death in the UK, with an estimated 74,000 deaths each year in England and over 113,000 deaths from smoking in the North East since the year 2000.

Friday, 31 July 2020

It’s not just teaching and curriculum that need a boost in September - what about school fruit and veg?

The School Fruit and Vegetable Scheme offers 2.3 million children aged 4 to 6 attending state-funded primary schools in England a free piece of fruit or veg each school day. It was suspended in March and after months of campaigning the Government finally confirmed the scheme will resume in the Autumn. But how could this Scheme go further to better meet Government aims?


Sofia Parente, Sustainable Food Places Policy & Campaigns Coordinator at Sustain: alliance for better food & farming

Credit: Pexels.com cottonbro
School holidays are upon us and this year, for the first time, 1.3 million UK children on free school meals will have access to support during July and August. Universal Infant Free School Meals and the School Fruit and Vegetable Scheme, suspended when schools closed in March, will be back in September. This should be cause for celebration but unfortunately, it’s not just teaching and curriculum needing a boost in September. Even in ‘normal times’ 80% of children were not eating their 5 A Day. Following lockdown, there’s been a massive decrease in fruit and vegetable intake reported by children receiving free school meals, according to a study from Northumbria University’s Healthy Living Lab. In this study just over half of pupils who would have received free school meals on site stated they had eaten no fresh vegetables across a three-day period following the UK’s COVID-19 lockdown. Vegetable intake dropped from just over two portions per day when children were attending school, to an average of half a portion per day at home. Almost half said they had eaten no fruit in the same period, yet many reported a large increase in their consumption of sugary drinks and snacks. 

As a school Governor and mother of two children in primary school, I’ve heard countless praises of the School Fruit and Vegetable Scheme. Children are naturally hungry mid-morning and fruit and vegetables are the perfect snack. By eating together in the classroom or playground, pupils try fruit and veg that they wouldn’t otherwise try at home. Only last week my niece (a fussy eater when it comes to veg) told me the first time she had ever tried sugar snap peas was in Year 2 when she had free fruit and veg at school. Teachers often integrate it in the curriculum too by using fruit and vegetables in numeracy and literacy lessons.

The reinstatement of the School Fruit and Vegetable Scheme is good news but still some way off when it comes to tackling historical low levels of fruit and veg consumption and under-investment in school food. It only reaches children in Key Stage 1 (pupils aged between 5 and 7) in England and there is no comparable scheme in Wales or Northern Ireland, although in Scotland some local authorities fund fruit in schools.

BIGGER

One of the best ways to ensure children increase access to fruit and vegetables at school is to bring back the scheme bigger and better and to introduce it to other nations in the UK. An efficient procurement process and network of delivery centres makes it possible to deliver 2.3 million pieces of fruit and vegetables to 16,600 schools in England every school day working out at around 8p per child per day. We’ve seen extraordinary progress in food and farming strategy this week. The first report from the National Food Strategy includes strong recommendations to address food poverty and inequality. And the Government’s obesity strategy has arguably some of the most ambitious new policies to date, particularly the 9pm advertising watershed for unhealthy food, with parallel restrictions online and on social media, along with constraints on promotions and progress on labelling. Expanding the scheme to all children in primary school using the set up already in place would be a remarkable value for money measure to help Government meet the ambitions of these two new strategies by helping to level off some of the inequalities in access to fresh fruit and vegetables and would be a game changer given the low levels of fruit and veg eaten by children. The latest evaluation of the scheme shows that while it leads to an increase in younger children eating fruit and veg, longer and integrated interventions would lead to long-lasting impact and sustained levels of consumption in older children.

Better

The first and easiest change to improve the scheme would be to increase the proportion of British seasonal fruit and veg produced to higher standards. According to the Soil Association, only 30-40% of this produce is grown in the UK. Why are we serving imported rock-hard apples to children in schools surrounded by apples in season in orchards in Kent and Somerset or to children anywhere in the UK come to that? This flagship Government procurement scheme should be supporting British farmers and traders, not least to support the aims of other Government departments, but to help the economy, especially now after Britain’s departure from the EU and the uncertainty in the food and farming sector triggered by COVID-19.

The School Fruit and Vegetable Scheme should be re-specified to provide a year-on-year percentage increase of seasonal and certified sustainable produce - such as the Organic or LEAF (Linking Environment And Farming) mark - to help drive towards the Government’s aims in the Environment Bill, Agriculture Bill and climate legislation. This would result in increased fruit and vegetable consumption and benefit British farmers, children and the environment.


Image: Credit: Pexels.com cottonbro

Friday, 22 February 2019

What old crisp packets dig up

Posted by Duika Burges Watson, Lecturer at Newcastle University based in the Institute of Health and Society

It appears that I’m an academic litter picker. I like to have hands on experience of topics I write and teach about. Inspired by the new module I’m leading on Global Health in the Anthropocene, and in particular a lecture on plastic pollution and health, I went litter picking. The Anthropocene is a new (ish) term to public health - considered to mark a turning point where “changes to the structure and function of the Earth's natural systems represent a growing threat to human health”[1].


I certainly found a good site for it. In less than 10 minutes from a 2 metre square area, I collected 69 crisp packets amongst the plastic bags and other items. I was intrigued, so I took them home and washed, sorted and ‘analysed’ them. Some use by dates were no longer visible, but of those I could read, 49 of 69 were Walkers crisp packets (parent company Pepsico) with use by dates from between 1996 to 2014. I went back the following weekend to the same site, dug a little deeper, and collected a further 89 crisp packets of which 51 were Walkers. The oldest packet was a Geordie company, Tudor (more on them later), with the use by date 10th January 1992.

Walkers bought out Newcastle
based company Tudor in 1987
There is a lot to be explored on crisp packets including use by dates, ingredients, health labelling and advertising.  Many even listed the time of production, often very late at night. For example, a Walkers smokey bacon use by 23rd June 2012 was made at 10.48pm. The irony of time was not lost on me in terms of the Anthopocene: we can know the exact minute the crisps were made (but not the date), they take about 2 minutes to eat and result in decades of rubbish.

Walkers began using foil bags in 1993 with plastic coatings. Yet people have been finding perfectly preserved plastic Walkers bags from the 80s in litter picking efforts. In September 2018, no doubt inspired by David Attenborough’s shocking profile of marine plastics in the series ‘Blue Planet’, the public started sending their bags back to Walkers. Royal Mail protested that people had to put them in envelopes first.

Walkers took up the challenge created by public protests. They have promised to find alternative solutions to the pesky bags by 2025, and until then have set up a recycling deal with company terracycle across the UK. There are collection points all over the UK.

But it wasn’t just the plastic pollution that concerned me. Crisp consumption is one of those things that people in public health worry about because these are classic examples of the high fat, salt, sugar foods where over-consumption can play havoc with our health. But we’ve been eating crisps for a long time, long before epidemics of obesity, and they have a cultural history to boot. A Brief History of Crisps (2012), suggests they were a British invention that turned up in the English edition of The Housekeeper’s Manual in 1829. The ‘modern’ industrial crisp really found its crunch after the first World War when the Smith’s company enrolled grocers and butchers across the UK to offer crudely made crisps (made in house with lots of fatty smells apparently). In the 1950s it all changed, technologies were imported from the USA and production scaled up. The first company to employ this technology was the previously mentioned Tudor. In 1967 they introduced the first ‘salt and vinegar’ chips to the UK market from their base in Sandyford, Newcastle. Tudor’s 1970s-80s commercials have a distinctly Geordie feel (note the ‘Dunstan Rocket’ in the first ad below – an iconic piece of architecture!). As a more recent immigrant to Newcastle, I had always wondered why every time I got served a sandwich it was with crisps – now I know – they have a proud Northern heritage. Walkers bought out the Tudor company in 1987.


In my ‘analysis’ of crisps, I have been wondering about their continued value as ‘food’. Is there a way we can still enjoy them as cultural icon without creating so much waste and without damaging our health? The one thing I’ve learned about food is that preferences change, tastes change – is the solution to learn to like something else? Last year the Walker’s crisp factory in Peterlee was bought by Heather Mills for her vegan food empire VBites. She is now looking to take over an abandoned factory in Northumberland. If successful, this would be the largest vegan food producing factory in the UK.

One of the sessions I’ll be leading in the Anthropocene module is on food – from source to senses. There is growing international concern about what kind of diet we ‘can’ eat if we want to protect and preserve the planet in the face of the Anthropocene and global climate change. The Eat Lancet Commission produced some rather controversial findings in January that offers their vision of what a ‘sustainable’ diet might involve[2]. Not unexpectedly, it involves cutting back on meat and eating more veg. Most agree that urgent change is required to farming systems and diet, but getting exactly the right mix of dietary components has created tensions. The Sustainable Food Trust, for example, points out that some land is not suitable for vegetable production and that grazing is the best option in some places. So, no simple solutions, and more debate to be had.

Another area of interest that will be covered in the course is new understanding of what it is that makes food ‘delicious’, how we ‘sense’ food, and what promotes ‘satiety’ or feelings of fullness. The ‘flavour’ of food involves a fusion of sensory inputs: smell, taste, colour, sound, trigeminal nerve stimulation[3], and our enjoyment of it is mediated by our culture, our history, our environment. Crisps are not difficult to figure out from a sensory perspective, like many other ‘fast’ foods, they are particularly heavy on salt, fat and sugar: what I would call ‘tongue’ foods. More complex ‘flavours’, particularly those involving smell, have been found to better trigger satiety – that’s why you can keep eating crisps without feeling full. But why do we like these ‘tongue foods’ so much? It’s complex; you’d have to join the course to explore this question.

So what about crisps then? Can we as public health researchers do more with ‘flavour’ to inspire different kinds of food choices? Could we encourage archaeological litter picking to engage the younger folk given so many foods are in single use plastics? People seem willing to give up plastic bags - could we encourage people to stop eating crisps until 2025 when they are in recyclable bags?  I don’t know the answer to these questions, but it will require more than litter picking to know. Food choice is academically interesting from a flavour point of view.  The crisp example throws up other challenges for public health - the Anthropocene creates interesting ethical questions about how we eat ‘beyond’ questions of the food itself. In March we will be running flavour masterclasses for the public where we get hands on to unpack the mystery of the humble crisp, why we like them, and what we should do about it! These questions are also being addressed by the Altered Eating Research Network (AERN) at Newcastle University, a new interdisciplinary collaboration that considers how our relationships with food are diverse, sometimes problematic, and how they intersect with the changing environments we live in and co-create. Keep an eye on the AERN website for details of flavour masterclasses and other upcoming events.


References:
  1. Whitmee, S., Haines, A., Beyrer, C., Boltz, F., Capon, A.G., de Souza Dias, B.F., Ezeh, A., Frumkin, H., Gong, P., Head, P. and Horton, R., 2015. Safeguarding human health in the Anthropocene epoch: report of The Rockefeller Foundation–Lancet Commission on planetary health. The Lancet, 386(10007), pp.1973-2028.
  2. Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT–Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems (Walter Willett et al.). https://www.thelancet.com/commissions/EAT
  3. The trigeminal nerve is responsible for sensations in the face and for motor control of biting and chewing. It is how we experience the ‘spiciness’ of food, the ‘coolness’ of mint or the ‘fizziness’ of carbonated drinks. Spence, C., Smith, B. and Auvray, M., 2015. Confusing tastes and flavours. Perception and its modalities, pp.247-274.

Friday, 18 January 2019

Sustainable diets must be a public health priority

Guest post by Tom Embury, Public Affairs Officer at the British Dietetic Association

The publication this week of the EAT-Lancet Commission report on healthy diets from sustainable food systems makes it clear that our health and the planets are inextricably linked. As such, improving the sustainability of our diets must be a public health priority. This is something that the British Dietetic Association (BDA) has recognised for some time, and we have recently launched our One Blue Dot toolkit to help dietitians, as key public health actors, deliver on that priority.
Pale Blue Dot - photograph of Earth taken by the Voyager 1 space probe

One Blue dot – the only home we have

The BDA chose to name our Environmentally Sustainable Diets Toolkit 'One Blue Dot' for the famous image taken by Voyager 1. It is of the Earth from a distance over 3.5 billion miles, and in it our planet appears as a pale blue speck, less than one pixel wide, in the vast darkness of space. The astronomer Carl Sagan said of the image:
"To my mind, there is perhaps no better demonstration of the folly of human conceits than this distant image of our tiny world. To me, it underscores our responsibility to deal more kindly and compassionately with one another and to preserve and cherish that pale blue dot, the only home we've ever known"
Our eating habits are having an adverse impact on the environment and we are endangering the future of the planet – up to 30% of greenhouse gas emissions (GHGe) come from the production of food – and it’s the only one we’ve got. We also know that our current food system is not providing for human health either. Over 800 million people worldwide still do not have enough to eat, while nearly two billion are now overweight or obese.

We believe that eating more sustainably can be a win-win – good for us and good for the planet. It’s also the responsible thing to do. As Ursula Arens, one of the dietetic experts who helped us write the toolkit put it: "Eat healthily for you, eat sustainably for your grandchildren".

Practical help

The BDA’s 2017 policy statement on sustainable diets emphasised the central role we believe dietitians need to play, translating the complex science of environmental sustainability as it relates to food into practical dietary advice for patients and the public at large. The statement was well received by our members but they also made it clear that we needed to do more to support them to make this policy a reality. This is a big topic and can be daunting, not just for the public but for healthcare professionals as well. That is why the idea for a toolkit was born, designed to provide a summary of the key evidence, some practical tools and links for more advice.

So far, we’ve developed a comprehensive reference guide which looks in detail at the key elements of a sustainable diet, outlines the evidence on the impact of certain foods on areas like GHGe, land use and water use. We’ve included practical meal swaps, which highlight the relatively easy ways in which common meals can be made both more nutritious and have less impact on the environment. We then include detailed information on specific nutritional considerations, in particular those nutrients that may be lacking if red meat is reduced and dairy intake moderated, such as calcium, iron and iodine.

Key recommendations

The main two recommendations within the toolkit are to reduce red and processed meat (RPM), and to moderate dairy intake. These two actions will lead to the biggest reduction in GHGe in particular, and we know that there are positive health benefits from reducing RPM and shifting away from certain dairy sources such as cheese which have high environmental impact and are also typically high in saturated fat and salt.

Other considerations, like sourcing sustainable fish, eating more fruit and veg, consuming locally produced food and reducing food waste will also make an important contribution to public health. No one action will be enough on its own. It becomes clear once you delve into the science and evidence on sustainable diets just how complex this issue is, and that even seemingly innocuous differences in the way (or indeed where) food is produced makes a big difference to its environmental impact.

What next

This toolkit is not finished; it remains a live document which we hope to add to and update over the coming months and years. While the first part is focused on dietitians themselves, we know that the next phase will be to make this a public health message. We’ve already got some more materials planned, and been delighted with all the questions and suggestions from dietitians and others about what we could look to include in future iterations. If you have any further suggestions, including on how this message can be translated for public health audiences, they’re very welcome!

We know that changing our diets alone will not save the planet - we also need to make big changes in transport, energy, waste and many more besides. However, as the experts in diet and health, it’s the area in which we have the expertise to make the biggest difference.

You can find out more about the One Blue Dot toolkit on the BDA website: www.bda.uk.com/onebluedot


Image: 'Carl-Sagan-Pale-Blue-Dot' by Owen Iverson via Flickr.com, copyright © 2006: https://www.flickr.com/photos/oweniverson/4671868416

Friday, 27 July 2018

Do councils have what they need to help tackle obesity?

Guest post by Michael Chang, Project and Policy Manager, Town & Country Planning Association

The new revised National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) is published by the Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government this week (24 July). It now provides the policy basis for planning healthy communities (Section 8 Paragraphs 91 and 92). In this context, here I want to explore whether there are enough planning powers to successfully tackle fast food outlets. At a Fuse event earlier this year on ‘Planning for Healthier diets: restricting hot food takeaway proliferation’, I also highlighted interesting results of recent planning policy developments and planning appeal decisions.
 

Back to the future… again?

Firstly it should be stated that concerns about the physical built environment and food environment in relation to people’s health and wellbeing are not a new trend. There has long been an understanding (with increasing supporting academic evidence) of the negative implications of food deserts and extant planning policies to tackle the negative environmental impacts from food outlets such as smells, noise, opening hours, litter and traffic generation.

The Foresight Tackling Obesities report was published in 2007 which, in the context of addressing the issue through a whole system approach, suggested two actions in which urban planners can effect change in the living environment, one of which refers to food and drink access and availability[1]. But a year earlier, the Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution, an independent standing body established in 1970 to advise the Queen, the Government, Parliament and the public on environmental issues, had already highlighted availability and cost of healthy food as an environmental determinant to cardiovascular risk in its seminal 26th report on The Urban Environment[2].

Is there an enabling policy environment to tackle obesity?

Given the weight of evidence, research and high-level recommendations in the last decade, in 2018, do planning practitioners working in local authorities have the right policy tools to do something about it? The main indicator is whether local plans, which each local authority across England have created, have the right policies? Local plans are powerful because in addition to setting out the council’s long-term vision and pathway for creating sustainable local communities, they are the basis with which decisions on planning applications are made from extensions to your house, to opening new shops on the high street to the creation of a complete new neighbourhood.

CEDAR (Centre for Diet and Activity Research) will publish more extensive results on local plans and fast food outlet policies so I will focus on the wider issue of tackling obesity. As part of the Planning Healthy Weight Environment work in 2014[3], the Town & Country Planning Association (TCPA) undertook an extensive policy review of local plans in England. Forty-one percent (41%) did reference obesity but generally only in the introductory paragraphs where they identified that obesity was a problem in the area. Only 17% followed through to the policy sections, but always in the supporting text rather than in the policy text. In statutory Joint Health and Wellbeing Strategies, only 31% make specific links to the built environment as one of the wider determinants of obesity. 

There is no reason, if supported by evidence and needs assessment, for councils not to have relevant policies such as on active travel, open space and food environment with a specific objective to help reduce local obesity rates. Recent planning inspector reports on draft local plans, before they are approved by councils, indicate a growing positive picture of a more welcoming stance on restricting fast food outlet policies including greater acceptance of the exclusion zone approach.

Have planning appeal decisions been favourable?

How are councils actually faring when they apply these policies in defending their decisions to refuse planning permission for new fast food outlets? The picture is more mixed with some councils successfully defending their decisions while many others have their decisions overturned by planning inspectors. The justifications by planning inspectors are not as you might expect.

"...this is politics, it's not medicine..." - 24 TV series
To illustrate the way planning appeals have been decided for and against planning applications for new fast food takeaways, take for example a scene from the hit American drama ‘24’. President Palmer’s advisor Wayne Palmer said to the President’s doctor Anne Packard: “It’s he said, she said, you see this is politics, it’s not medicine, so do me a favour and stay out of it”. 

Most, if not all the recent judgements I have seen (but there would need to be a more systematic review), do reference national guidance and support the obesity crisis as a valid planning reason. The health and medical arguments appear to have been won, but other wider considerations including local ‘political’ issues come into play and only evidence presented on the day are valid. This scene underlies the tension in planning decisions, which is why in its three reports into the government’s Childhood Obesity Plan in the last three years, the Health and Social Care Select Committee[4] has consistently called for health to be a material planning consideration in an arena of competing considerations from economic to employment.

What does this all means?

There needs to be more research done in the area to better understand the implications of proliferation of fast food outlets on population health from the health inequalities lens. There also needs to be more applied research to understand why practitioners could not effectively implement policies and what the real barriers are. Evidence and aspiration can only go so far. It is time we all take a breather from pursuing perfect evidence to properly supporting practitioners at the coal-face.


Michael Chang is a Chartered Town Planner at the Town and Country Planning Association (TCPA), leads on TCPA’s Reuniting Health with Planning Initiative and currently undertaking a part time Master by Research at Leeds Beckett University on using planning powers to promote healthy weight environments.


References:
  1. Foresight, 2007, Tackling Obesities: Future Choices: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/reducing-obesity-future-choices  
  2. Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution (RCEP), 2006, The Urban Environment: http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20110322144101/http://www.rcep.org.uk/reports/26-urban/documents/urban-environment.pdf
  3. Town & Country Planning Association (TCPA), 2014, Planning Healthy-weight environments: https://www.tcpa.org.uk/Handlers/Download.ashx?IDMF=7166d749-288a-4306-bb74-10b6c4ffd460
  4. Health and Social Care Select Committee, Childhood obesity inquiries reports 2015, 2017 and 2018: 

Images:
  1. "318-365 Year3 On Our Way Home" by John Garghan via Flickr.com, copyright © 2011: https://www.flickr.com/photos/johngarghan/6351566649
  2. By The original uploader was Tuxo at German Wikipedia. [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:24-Logo.svg

Friday, 15 June 2018

The Government’s new Clean Air Strategy – hope or hype?

Dr Susan Hodgson, lecturer in Environmental Epidemiology and Exposure Assessment at the MRC-PHE Centre for Environment and Health, Imperial College London

© 2018 Imperial College London
Air pollution was been high on the agenda at Imperial College London recently, with Environment Secretary Michael Gove choosing to launch the Government’s new Clear Air Strategy at Imperial’s Data Science Institute[1]. To coincide with this launch, Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt announced a new tool, developed by Imperial and the UK Health Forum, to help local authorities estimate the health-care costs due to air pollution - an estimated £157 million from exposure to fine particulates and nitrogen dioxide across England in 2017[2].

Academics and researchers worldwide have worked over many decades to produce an evidence base of high quality research which now clearly links air pollution and health. Globally, 4.2 million deaths are attributed to outdoor air pollution, with 91% of the world’s population living in areas where air quality exceeds health-based guidance limits[3]. Figures for the UK also make grim reading, with an estimated 40,000 deaths per year attributable to outdoor air pollution[4]. While research on this topic makes an unequivocal case for action, Government policy to improve air quality for public health has been found lacking, with the UK (along with France, Germany, Hungary, Italy and Romania) being taken to the European court of Justice for failing to meet EU limits for nitrogen dioxide.

© 2018 Imperial College London
The new Clear Air Strategy[5] outlines how the Government plans to protect the nation’s health. The stated intention of halving the number of people living where concentrations of fine particulate matter are above 10μg/m3 - the concentration of an air pollutant is given in micrograms (one-millionth of a gram) per cubic meter air or 'µg/m3' - by 2025, if achieved, would reap a significant health dividend. However, the focus on a ‘personal air quality messaging system to inform the public…about the air quality forecast [and] air pollution episodes’ places onus on individuals to avoid exposure, rather than creating clean and safe environments within which to live. While there is a place for such messaging, when more than 2000 education/childcare providers across England and Wales are within 150m of a road breaching the legal limit for Nitrogen dioxide pollution (25 of which are in the North East and more than 1500 in London)[6], is it clear that a population based approach is required to tackle this pressing public health issue.

The Strategy also restates the previously announced plan to phase out conventional petrol and diesel cars and vans by 2040, to be replaced by zero exhaust emissions vehicles. This is a positive step, but not sufficient to tackle traffic-related pollution. What comes out of the exhaust represents less than half of vehicle emissions; ‘clean’ vehicles will still generate pollution from tyre and brake wear, and re-suspension of road dust, as explained by Imperial PhD student Liza Selley in her 2016 Max Perutz Science Writing Award-winning essay[7].

The Strategy proposes steps to address not just road traffic pollution, but also shipping, aviation, agriculture and industry, and links health, the environment and economy, marking a welcome move away from silo thinking. There is also mention of ‘appraisal tools and accompanying guidance…to enable the health impacts of air pollution to be considered in every relevant policy decision that is made’ – it is not clear if this extends beyond policy decisions on air pollution, i.e. represents a move towards a coherent ‘health in all’ approach[8], but, if so, would represent a welcome prioritisation of health across Government departments.

© 2018 Imperial College London
Focussing on cleaner vehicles and technological solutions can only offer a partial solution to reducing the impact of air pollution on health, so it is good to see modal shift towards public transport and active transport is mentioned (briefly) in the Strategy. There are funds to support bus and rail infrastructure to improve public transport, and an ambition to double the levels of cycling by 2025 - though this would only raise levels from 2% to 4%, compared to 39% in the Netherlands[9].

If the Government is serious about adopting a more holistic approach to the environment, health and economy, then I feel far more could have been made of the great potential to tackle air quality, sustainability and health collectively. We need ambition and vision to create sustainable cities, and approaches to transport and living that reduce air pollution and additionally tackle inactivity and obesity, which are key drivers of population health. Barcelona’s Institute for Global Health recently launched its #CitiesWeWant initiative[10], which highlights some of the features we need to be prioritising in our cities to benefit future health and wellbeing. We have the research evidence to support these priorities, but Governments will require buy-in from experts and demand from the public to enact bold change. Those passionate about improving our environment for health have the opportunity to voice their views via the Government consultation on this newly launched Clear Air Strategy, which will inform a National Air Pollution Control Programme due March 2019.


The views represented here are those of the author, Dr Susan Hodgson.

Susan is a lecturer in environmental epidemiology and exposure assessment at the MRC- PHE Centre for Environment and Health at Imperial College London. Her research focusses on understanding how interactions with our environment (including air pollution), influences health.

More details at: www.imperial.ac.uk/people/susan.hodgson


References:
  1. https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/186390/michael-gove-launches-governments-clean-air/
  2. https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/186406/air-pollution-england-could-cost-much/
  3. http://www.who.int/airpollution/en/
  4. https://www.rcplondon.ac.uk/projects/outputs/every-breath-we-take-lifelong-impact-air-pollution
  5. https://consult.defra.gov.uk/environmental-quality/clean-air-strategy-consultation/user_uploads/clean-air-strategy-2018-consultation.pdf   
  6. https://unearthed.greenpeace.org/2017/04/04/air-pollution-nurseries/
  7. http://www.insight.mrc.ac.uk/2016/10/14/braking-perceptions-of-traffic-pollution/
  8. http://www.who.int/healthpromotion/frameworkforcountryaction/en/
  9. https://ec.europa.eu/transport/road_safety/specialist/knowledge/pedestrians/pedestrians_and_cyclists_unprotected_road_users/walking_and_cycling_as_transport_modes_en
  10. https://www.isglobal.org/en/ciudadesquequeremos

Friday, 2 June 2017

Can we achieve a healthy sustainable diet by 2030?

Guest post by Christian Reynolds, Knowledge Exchange Research Fellow (N8 AgriFood project), Department of Geography, Faculty of Social Sciences, The University of Sheffield.

I recently attended the REFRESH Food Waste 2017 conference in Berlin. In the keynote speech of the conference, Vytenis Andriukaitis, (Lithuania's European Commissioner and designate responsible for Health and Food Safety) closed with the remark that Europe’s target is to halve food waste by 2030, and asked the audience if the goal of halving food waste is feasible or a fairy tale promise? 2030 is only 13 years away after all!


Likewise, the sustainable development goals are aimed for 2030, these include: ending poverty, ending hunger, increasing good health and well-being, climate action, and ensuring sustainable consumption and production patterns – the latter encompassing the aim to halve food waste.

Many of these goals require large changes to production methods and systems, modes of consumption, and general societal shifts on a global scale. This got me thinking about the challenge of shifting populations towards healthy, sustainable diets; is 2030 an achievable and realistic time frame?

Over the last couple of years there have been a few studies discussing how the UK, and global diets need to shift to meet healthy sustainable diets, (I will admit that I also have two in peer review at the moment). Some of my favourite studies currently published are Macdiarmid et al (2012), Green et al (2015), and van Dooren et al (2015). I also recommend reading Dantzig (1990) to get a glimpse of how this field of enquiry began.

These studies use mathematical modelling methods such as linear programming to calculate diets that:
  1. are optimised to be sustainable (for most studies this means low in associated greenhouse gas emissions (GHGE));
  2. meet the current healthy eating guidelines; and
  3. are not ‘unacceptable’ to the population.
This final item is a crucial, as if you do not constrain for palatability, the linear programme will calculate diets that are healthy, but only feature the foods with lowest environmental impacts. For example, Macdiarmid et al (2012) found a diet of 7 foods: whole-grain breakfast cereal, pasta, peas, fried onions, brassicas, sesame seeds, and confectionery to be sustainable and healthy. Stigler (1945) on the other hand proposed the following 7 foods: wheat flour, evaporated milk, cabbage, spinach, dried navy beans, pancake flour, and pork liver. Both of these are very ‘worthy’ but not varied enough diets to pass muster with the general population.

With this acceptability constraint in play, diets that are healthy and have lower GHGE are achievable with as little as 20-40% dietary shift resulting in up to 30% reduction in GHGEs (see Figure 3 from Green et al (2015). The majority of the studies include a reduction in animal products. For instance Macdiarmid et al (2012)’s sustainable diet featured 60% of the current intake of all meat for women in the United Kingdom and 48% of the intake of red meat (see Figure 1 from Macdiarmid et al 2012).

Figure 3. Deviations of optimised diets from current average diet, with associated reduction in greenhouse gas emissions from Green et al 2015
Figure 1. Proportions (by weight) of food groups in the final sustainable diet compared with the average current intake
of women in the United Kingdom (National Diet and Nutrition Survey 2008–2010). from Macdiarmid et al 2012





So are these changes in food consumption and purchase reasonable in a 13-year time period? Can we shift towards a healthy sustainable diet in 13 years?

For a quick check I looked up the rate of dietary change in the historic reports of the Family Food Survey. Looking over 13 year periods from 1945 to 2000, I found differing rates of changes in consumption and purchase for each food item (check out these amazing visualisations of Britain’s diet from 1945-2000, or look at the table I provide below).

Within all the 13 year periods between 1945 to 2000, all food groups have at maximum shifted by over 20%. This is good news, and indicates that change is possible for all food items in the British diet. However, what is less heartening is that total consumption and purchase of meat and meat products has only shifted by a maximum of 40%, while beef and veal consumption has only changed by a maximum of 47%. These rates of change need to be this high - if not higher - if we are to successfully shift toward a healthy sustainable diet.

So are healthy sustainable diets achievable or just a goal? Only time will tell. However, for now, here are some things that we can do to help the shift towards healthy sustainable diets:
  1. Focus on the foods that need to shift for both health and sustainability. Studies are finding that we need to increase fruit and vegetable consumption, increase oily fish consumption and reduce red meat and processed meat consumption. These are the main goals that we can work towards across the population.
  2. Pick our battles: focus on the foods that people have an appetite to change. From the table below we can see there are some foods that are easier to shift than others, for example starchy foods (a core of many British diets) have had much smaller rates of change than fruits and vegetables. Our relationship is already used to changing fruit and vegetable consumption, let’s focus there instead. 
  3. Technology and dietary change is our friend, let’s harness it. As society and technology develops, food consumption changes. Look at the changes in consumption of canned vegetables as better quality fresh vegetables were introduced. Likewise, the reduction in flour consumption as ready-made bread and other starches (rice, pasta, etc.) began to appear in the shops. How can we work with modern technology, such as improved food storage and processing technology, faster food transfer, and the advent of online shopping? Can we make online meal deliveries and food box deliveries lead to healthier and more sustainable diets?
Table: Britain’s diet from 1945-2000

Maximum 13 year change in food consumption/purchase 1945-2000Minimum 13 year change in food consumption/purchase 1945-2000
Liquid wholemilk 65.3%4.4%
Skimmed milk 99.0%0.0%
Yoghurt and fromage frais73.0%0.0%
Total milk and cream 27.8%4.5%
Natural cheese 23.0%0.0%
Processed cheese44.3%0.0%
Total cheese 44.1%8.5%
Eggs 67.1%7.5%
Oranges and other citrus fruit 74.0%16.1%
Apples and pears26.9%10.3%
Bananas64.6%9.1%
Total fresh fruit 61.0%13.0%
Fruit juice 88.4%25.0%
Total other 50.4%9.6%
Total Fruit 68.3%11.4%
Potatoes38.8%13.2%
Fresh green vegetables36.8%15.2%
Other fresh vegetables24.5%7.8%
Canned vegetables92.0%11.5%
Frozen vegetables77.3%0.0%
Other vegetables and products 42.9%10.5%
Total vegetables and products22.2%6.9%
Bread33.9%9.4%
Flour63.3%18.7%
Cakes and pastries60.2%12.7%
Biscuits66.0%4.9%
Break-fast cereal55.8%11.4%
Total cereals (excluding bread) 19.9%5.0%
Bread & cereal products 23.1%6.4%
Sugar54.0%8.6%
Preserves 51.9%21.3%
Tea37.9%9.4%
Coffee52.3%15.0%
Total beverages 28.2%6.0%
Fresh white fish49.0%17.2%
Fresh fat fish65.3%32.3%
Shellfish71.7%38.5%
Cooked fish61.9%29.0%
Total fish and fish products 46.2%6.1%
Butter67.5%10.8%
Margarine82.8%24.0%
Lard82.1%9.6%
All other fats 74.0%23.4%
Vegetable and oils64.1%0.0%
Low fat spreads53.8%0.0%
Reduced fat spreads80.0%0.0%
Total fats 37.4%5.0%
Beef and veal47.4%19.5%
Mutton and lamb55.4%17.6%
Pork95.8%27.7%
Bacon and ham68.3%7.5%
Pork, bacon and ham75.9%11.1%
Poultry90.0%15.6%
Sausages38.0%8.6%
Total meat and meat products39.8%8.6%

Christian Reynolds
Email: C.Reynolds@sheffield.ac.uk
Twitter: @sartorialfoodie


Photo attribution: "2006_04_10 Food waste. Peering into a dumpster at the GI Market." by Taz © 2006: https://secure.flickr.com/photos/sporkist/126526910