Showing posts with label South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. Show all posts
Showing posts with label South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. Show all posts

Friday, 1 April 2022

Breaking down barriers in End of Life care

Posted by Colette Hawkins, Consultant in Palliative Medicine, South Tees NHS Foundation Trust

Health research achieves extraordinary things. There are countless examples of life-changing, disease preventing or curative treatments. These are rightly celebrated and have shaped our society, as well as our expectations, around health and illness.
Break Through 1995 "Walls break hearts, hearts break walls" by 
Pierre Marcel via Flickr © 2011 (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)


But what about people living with a life-limiting illness and those approaching end of life? Health professionals often struggle to move away from an interventional, disease-focussed approach to a more holistic, person-centred approach. This risks unwanted intervention and missed opportunities for choice. This is mirrored by health research. In the UK, just 0.21% of health research is focussed on palliative and end of life care.

The reality is that people living towards end of life really struggle and whilst this may be directly related to ill-health, it is often issues of daily life which incapacitate them. These are generally overlooked by health professionals.

Since 2017, I have been involved in running research on legal needs in life-limiting illness. One element of this is social welfare legal needs (SWL): matters of daily life for which the law defines rights, entitlements and protections. In the context of life-limiting illness, the ‘big three’ are issues relating to money, employment and housing. These are prevalent, impacting most people in some way. However, their greatest impact is on people who are already disadvantaged, for example those experiencing homelessness, financial insecurity or debt, socially excluded or marginalised groups and people with multiple physical and/or mental illness. These people experience the most SWL needs, are most affected by them and are least likely to access support successfully.

Social welfare legal needs will often be presented to health professionals, wrapped up in a person’s physical complaints, but missed in favour of a focus on disease. So where else could they go? Our foundation research scoped the system of support for these issues. A wide range of services beyond health and social care provide advice and support for SWL needs, including charities, community groups, advice sector, legal services, social services, Jobcentre, housing groups, social prescribing, statutory organisations and more.

But if we took months to map the system (and it’s still growing), can we expect people in vulnerable and difficult situations to find their way?

Funded by the NIHR Applied Research Collaboration (ARC) North East and North Cumbria (NENC), our research has engaged members of the public with lived experience, as well as service providers in Gateshead, to find an effective system response to social welfare legal needs. We used Human Learning Systems, an approach which accepts the complexity of a system and supports co-produced responses to need founded on continuous learning.

Engagement of people with lived experience of life-limiting illness and SWL needs proved critical to the value of this project. Focus group discussions revealed the scale of the challenge to manage SWL needs. The walls they faced included not feeling heard, not knowing where to go for help, lack of information to help themselves, lack of responsibility from professionals or services, poor communication between services and long delays to resolution (or non-resolution). These insights, along with those of service providers, told us that the ideal system response should be founded on relationships and offering information, problem solving and a joined up approach. This seems quite obvious and appropriate, so why are there so many walls?

Attitudes and structures 

The walls come from two main sources: professional attitudes and structures. Attitudes obstruct when they use labels, stereotypes or assumptions, treat illness, not people, miss opportunities for honest discussion, restrict choice through failing to listen to priorities and wishes, overlook responsibility for holistic needs and forget to work in partnership. Structures maintain silos and fragmentation of care with the lack of clear routes to advice and support, boundaries to access through geography, referral criteria or social context, expectations that patients and carers will self-advocate and navigate themselves and missed opportunities to capitalise on the expertise of others. These walls obstruct identification and management of social welfare legal needs and amplify inequalities in care towards end of life.

We believe interprofessional learning is a route to breaking down these walls. We use short stories of experience instead of ‘sterile’ clinical cases, and facilitate discussion to explore what matters most, and the approaches to meeting needs in an inclusive, respectful and effective way. Initial pilots have shown that this is a route to closer integration of services, although the latest pilot, within the ARC project, also highlighted the challenge of engagement with online learning, accentuated by the pressure and workplace fatigue linked to COVID-19. Feedback showed that people felt too busy to attend or just didn’t turn up on the day.

We have secured a NIHR End of Life Partnership grant which we are using to co-design a research strategy for evaluation of system-wide learning around SWL needs in life-limiting illness. We are re-evaluating what we mean by ‘end of life’, pushing beyond traditional views and including people at risk of premature death. We are broadening our insight into the inequalities and prejudices embedded within care of people who may be living towards end of life. We can see the walls; our task is to break them down.


This project ‘Integrating care to meet social welfare legal needs in life-limiting illness. Qualitative investigation of a multi-agency, complexity-informed intervention’ has been funded by by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) [Applied Research Collaboration North East and North Cumbria (NIHR200173)]. The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care.


Image: Break Through 1995 "Walls break hearts, hearts break walls" by Pierre Marcel via Flickr © 2011: https://www.flickr.com/photos/21063155@N06/5409729627 (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

Friday, 10 May 2019

Why do some women continue to smoke when they are pregnant?

Guest post by Susan Jones, Research Associate, Teesside University
"I was 12 years old when I started to smoke. I wasn’t thinking long-term, about my future, about the adult world I would one day join … I just wanted to look cool among my peers, be accepted and act grown up. Then I really did grow up and I was still smoking. Then I became pregnant … and I was still smoking. I didn’t exactly choose to be a smoker when I was pregnant but here I am ... addicted and not really wanting to give it up, or even if I wanted to, I don’t think I could – even for my baby.
"My mam smoked when she was pregnant with me, and I’ve turned out all right; all my family smokes, all my friends smoke, my partner smokes too; in fact smoking is a part of all my close relationships, especially with my partner, we smoke together, it is part of how our relationship works."

"I feel guilty, oh so guilty, but I can’t, I really can’t give up – I simply do not have the confidence to do it. I know that ‘smoking is bad for my baby’; I care for my baby and don’t want to do anything that would cause harm, and I’m really looking after myself, eating well, not drinking any more. I’ve cut down but I hardly dare think about quitting smoking, how on earth would I cope? And my partner, he’s not willing to change his smoking habits, or at least he’s agreed he’ll just not breathe over me when he’s been smoking, but he’s not even prepared to cut down – all he does is tell me, you must quit for the sake of the baby."
 
A composite from interviews with pregnant smokers and maternity staff.



Smoking is highly addictive and habit forming; many people enjoy the feeling it brings too[1]. Nevertheless the damage from smoking to the developing baby is well documented and the high level of smoking in pregnancy is still a major public health concern[2]. The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) Public Health Guidance 26 (2010)[3] sets out all the trial-based evidence relating to the activities health professionals should take to support pregnant women to quit smoking. BabyClear© is a programme that supports health professionals to implement NICE guidance and provides standard training for them in order to carry out the activities in the most effective ways[4].

When we evaluated the implementation of the babyClear© package during its roll-out across North East England, we found that, for healthcare practitioners to challenge smoking behaviour amongst pregnant women, there needs to be a whole support system in place for both the professionals and the women whose behaviour they seek to change[5].

We recently developed an animation, based on our findings, which you can watch here:




South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust took part in the evaluation of the implementation of the babyClear© package and works closely with its local stop smoking service. As Joanna Feeney, the Smokefree NHS Strategic Manager, says:
"South Tees is a great example of how Stop Smoking Services and Maternity Services can work together to help support Pregnant women to have Smokefree Pregnancies. 
"Most women who smoke during their pregnancy may know that smoking is bad but they are not aware of all the risks to them or to baby, they are also not aware of the help and support that is available to quit, including treatments such as Nicotine Replacement Therapy. 
"Implementing advice and treatment as part of routine Maternal care that is continued outside of hospital with the Stop Smoking Service helps ensure that babies are given the best start in life. 
"Last year in South Tees there were 334 more babies born Smokefree compared to 2012, and this year following the great work done on the wards at James Cook University Hospital the numbers are continuing to reduce but we recognise that there is still more to be done to ensure that every baby is born smokefree."
The Maternity and Stop Smoking Services reviewed the referral pathway and developed an online referral system that not only makes it easier for midwives but increases the speed with which women are contacted and given an appointment with the Stop Smoking Service.

Image courtesy of South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
The Stop Smoking Service provides regular feedback to Maternity on the outcomes of women referred, enabling Maternity to offer bespoke interventions to those women who do not engage with treatment.

A further example of how South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust has moved towards a whole support system and worked in close partnership with stop smoking services is an initiative they undertook last year to redecorate the entrance to their maternity unit using eye-catching posters with a strong, stop smoking message.

And now, a year on, Kay Branch, Consultant Public Health midwife, South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust says:
"We are still really proud to have led the way towards a smokefree Trust. Our staff have noticed a reduction in the presence of anyone smoking outside entrances. 
"We continue to work collaboratively with the local stop smoking service to ensure a streamlined service for women and their partners. Nicotine replacement therapy is available to all of our patients and is widely used across maternity. 
"Our smoking at time of delivery reflects our hard work and passion for smokefree families."
Maternity’s lead has inspired the whole Trust to implement a systematic approach to treating tobacco dependency with Maternity being the model ward.



I would encourage you to take a look at the animation above and publications relating to the roll-out of the babyClear© intervention package across the North East region. Please do share them with commissioners and providers of services, but also your colleagues, family and friends and any pregnant smokers you know.

More information on our evaluation work can be found here on the Fuse website.



References:
  1. Chamberlain, C., O'Mara-Eves, A., Porter, J., Coleman, T., Perlen, S. M. et al. (2017) Psychosocial interventions for supporting women to stop smoking in pregnancy. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Accessed on 18/03/19 at: https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD001055.pub5/epdf/full
  2. Bauld, L., Graham, H., Sinclair, L., Flemming, K., Naughton, F. et al. (2017) Barriers to and facilitators of smoking cessation in pregnancy and following childbirth: literature review and qualitative study. Health Technology Assessment, 21(36). https://www.journalslibrary.nihr.ac.uk/hta/hta21360#/abstract
  3. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (2010) Quitting smoking in pregnancy and following childbirth: public health guidance 26. NICE: London https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ph26/resources/smoking-stopping-in-pregnancy-and-after-childbirth-pdf-1996240366789
  4. Bell, R., Glinianaia, S. V., Van der Waal, Z., Close, A., Moloney, E., Jones, S., Araujo-Soares, V., Hamilton, S., Milne, E., Shucksmith, J., Vale, L., Willmore, M., White, M., Rushton, S. (2018) Evaluation of a complex healthcare intervention to increase smoking cessation in pregnant women: interrupted time series analysis with economic evaluation. Tobacco Control, 27: 1. Accessed on 18/03/19 at: http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/tobaccocontrol-2016-053476
  5. Jones, S.E., Hamilton, S., Bell, R. Araújo-Soares, V., Glinianaia, S.V., Milne, E.M.G., White, M., Willmore, M., Shucksmith, J. What helped and hindered implementation of an enhanced package of measures to reduce smoking in pregnancy: process evaluation guided by Normalization Process Theory. BMC Health Services Research [In press]