Showing posts with label stereotypes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label stereotypes. Show all posts

Friday, 14 October 2022

Media representations of disabled people

Posted by Laura Navin, Health and Social Care student, Northumbria University

Picture by Laura Navin
Negative media representations of disabled people still exist in society and this needs to be addressed. I have dyspraxia which is a learning difficulty, and I sometimes struggle with my co-ordination, communication, processing and speed but it has not stopped me from achieving my goals!

In the media, disability tends to be portrayed through a medical or deficit model, with disabled people often treated as pathetic.1,2,3 TV charity shows such as Children in Need encourage pity for disabled people2 and people with disabilities are still seen as “the heavy burden of care”; “the helpless victim”.3 Yet even when well-meaning, encouraging pity is discriminatory as it creates stereotypical and negative assumptions about disabled people2. These negative representations can decrease a disabled person’s self-esteem and make them feel like they are not part of society.1,4

The issue is heightened by the absence of disabled people and their voices within mainstream media which might help to reclaim the narrative and counter negative stereotypes. As Caroline Casey, founder of The Valuable 500, a global movement putting disability on the business leadership agenda, has suggested “from daytime TV to adverts on social media, to the articles which publications run, representation and visibility of persons with disabilities simply does not reflect our society”. This was brought to light recently for example, when Sia’s decision to cast a neurotypical actress in the role of an autistic female protagonist in her upcoming film was widely criticised.

There are more positive portrayals of disability in the media however. Harry Potter star, Daniel Radcliffe has dyspraxia and acted as an inspiration to many when saying, “do not let it stop you. It has never held me back.”. In 2018, Lee Ridley from the North East won Britain’s Got Talent and in 2021, EastEnders star Rose Ayling-Ellis became the first deaf contestant on Strictly Come Dancing. Even these more positive representations are emblematic of the failure to represent disabled people as everyday, ordinary citizens however. As Lee Ridley claims, “Our government has a very weird relationship with disabled people. We are either seen as superhuman or as some sort of burden”.

Portrayals of disabled people as a burden on society have been shown throughout both austerity and the Coronavirus pandemic. Disabled people have been mocked as ‘scroungers’ in television shows and newspapers, with arguments that incapacity benefit had become a ‘lifestyle choice’ for the lazy, and that a disability benefit crisis was responsible for the UK economic crash resulting in the disproportionate targeting of disabled people within austerity measures.5,6 Covid has been argued to be one of the biggest media outbreaks medicalising disabled people.1,7 During the pandemic, disabled people were seen as ‘vulnerable’ and had to isolate from society.5,8 ‘Vulnerable’ is a label that is often rejected by people with disabilities and its adoption does not portray the importance of disabled people’s rights and viewpoints.9 Labels such as ‘vulnerable’ or ‘immunocompromised’ when used to explain differential susceptibility to illness have also been argued to result in an unreasonable, unpleasant message about the value of disabled people’s lives. The sunflower lanyard which could be worn by disabled people to show they were exempt from wearing face masks helped in some ways to increase disability awareness and create more understanding, support and respect towards disabled people. However, this is another form of labelling, and not all disabled people want to identify their disability to the world. Greater understanding and training on disability ethics is urgently needed to avoid this sort of discrimination and support disabled rights more systemically.9,10

 

It is also important that disabled voices are heard in society and that the media represents disabled people in a more positive light. Sometimes when I tell people about my dyspraxia they feel pity for me, but this is not what I want. I am telling my story to inspire others, not create sympathy, so please do not feel sad for me, feel happy for me! I have succeeded in my academic studies and graduated from university with second-class honours as a student with dyspraxia. I have been involved in podcasts and dissertation writing to raise my voice as a disabled person and in doing so I hope to give others the confidence to do the same. I am now studying for a postgraduate certificate in education (PGCE) to teach health and social care. I hope to continue to raise my voice and to inspire others.


Part of our Fuse blog Student Series
The Fuse blog Student Series showcases posts by students who have been challenged to write a blog as part of their studies at one of the universities in the Fuse collaboration, the NIHR School for Public Health Research, or perhaps further afield. The authors may be new to blogging and we hope to provide a 'safe space' for the students to explore their subject and find their voice in the world of public health research.

The views and opinions expressed by the author are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Northumbria University or Fuse, the Centre for Translational Research in Public Health.


References

1) Cameron, C. (2014) Disability Studies: A student’s guide. London: SAGE Publications Ltd.

2) Barnes, C. (1992) Disabling imagery and the media: an exploration of the principles for media representations of disabled people. Halifax, England: The British Council of Organisations and Disabled People and Ryburn Publishing Limited.

3) Goethals, T. et al. (2020) ‘I am not your metaphor: frames and counter-frames in the representation of disability’, Disability & Society, 12 (1), pp.1-19. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09687599.2020.1836478.

4) Casey, C. (2020) ‘Where all the disabled people on screen? We must increase representation or risk reinforcing damaging stereotypes’, Independent, 1 December. Available at: Where are all the disabled people on screen? We must increase representation or risk reinforcing damaging stereotypes | The Independent (Accessed: 22 March 2022).

5) Ryan, F. (2019) Crippled: austerity and the demonization of disabled people. London: Verso.

6) Briant, E. et al. (2013) ‘Reporting disability in the age of austerity: the changing face of media representation of disability and disabled people in the United Kingdom and the creation of new ‘folk devils’, Disability & Society, 28 (6), pp.874-889. DOI: 10.1080/09687599.2013.813837.

7) Shakespeare, T. et al. (2021) ‘Triple jeopardy: disabled people and the COVID-19 pandemic’, The Lancet, 397(10282), pp.1331-1333. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(21)00625-5.

8) Courtenay, K. and Perera, B. (2020) ‘COVID-19 and people with intellectual disability: impacts of a pandemic’, Irish Journal of Psychological Medicine, 37, pp.231-236. DOI: 10.1017/ipm.2020.45.

9) Singh, S. (2020) ‘Disability ethics in the coronavirus crisis’, Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care, 9 (5), pp.2167-2171. DOI: 10.4103/jfmpc.jfmpc_588_20.

10) McLean, S. and Williamson, L. (2007) Impairment and disability: Law and ethics at the beginning and end of life. Oxon: Routledge-Cavendish.

Friday, 19 November 2021

Tackling stereotypes, stigma and self-help: What 'BoroManCan' is doing for the health and wellbeing of Boro Men

Posted by Shelina Visram, Senior Lecturer in Public Health, and Mabel Lie, Research Associate, from Newcastle University

It’s that time of year again… No, we’re not talking about Christmas. Today is International Men’s Day! If you’ve got no idea what this is, you may want to read the Fuse blog we wrote on the same day last year. The theme for 2021 is ‘Better relations between men and women’, recognising the need to promote gender equality for women as well as men. Which sounds good to us, as two female researchers who’ve been working on a men’s health project for the past year.

In last year’s blog we mentioned being awarded funding from the NIHR ARC NE&NC to conduct research into the BoroManCan campaign, which aims to inspire positive change around men’s health and wellbeing in Middlesbrough and Redcar & Cleveland. Colleagues from Public Health South Tees were keen to know which elements of BoroManCan were working and where improvements could be made. In collaboration with academics from Durham and Teesside Universities, we interviewed staff, representatives of partner organisations and other key stakeholders to capture their views on BoroManCan. We also trained and supported three peer researchers to gather insights from local men (and one woman). They chose to conduct interviews to explore men’s health and wellbeing needs, to help us understand whether BoroManCan could be doing more to improve their access to health services and other sources of support.

The interviews provided valuable insights into barriers to men’s help-seeking behaviour. To start with, Teesside’s industrial heritage has led to an expectation that the stereotypical ‘Boro man’ should be tough, resilient, and able to fulfil the roles of household provider and protector. Industrial decline, increasing unemployment and job insecurity were felt to have impacted negatively on men’s mental health. There was a general perception that men are not as likely as women to talk about their feelings or their health, and that there is a particular stigma to discussing mental health problems. Rather than accessing formal services, many Boro men prefer to avoid embarrassment by attempting self-help or using coping strategies such as excessive alcohol consumption and substance misuse. Apart from wanting to maintain their masculine image, there were also practical hurdles around demands from employment and the benefits system.

Two of the three peer researchers, Matthew (left) and Neil (right)
But it’s not all doom and gloom. We also identified a number of factors that were felt to impact positively on men’s health and wellbeing and their likelihood of seeking help. These included: having support from a partner or family members; activities such as Men’s Sheds that value life skills; creating male-friendly spaces; and providing opportunities to spend time outdoors. Some interviewees emphasised the importance of sport and particularly football as a way to connect with other men. What was clear was that apart from addressing men’s health within existing services, male-specific interventions such as BoroManCan were needed. The campaign was viewed positively as a way of sharing inspirational stories from others who have dealt with their own challenges, as well as signposting to relevant activities. Online elements such as the website and podcast were key to the campaign, particularly during the pandemic. However, staff and stakeholders were keen to return to offline elements such as the men’s health champion training and showcase events. Local men believed that the campaign needed to be promoted more widely to ensure it was reaching all those who might benefit.

Here's what our stakeholders had to say about the campaign:
"So I think one of the really good things about it [BoroManCan] is it's very specific to Middlesbrough. And obviously when you look at the stats, you know, you look at suicide rates and mental health in Middlesbrough, they're really high and I think men do struggle to engage. But when local men that are very similar to them are engaging, I think it helps other people." (Stakeholder 1)
"When people feel anxious, they're feeling alone. And BoroManCan, it was a way forward for them not to feel alone and to be able to share their story and find a way forward. 'Cos BoroManCan, it leads onto other things. If you share your story, you’re finding you're not alone. You find out how other people have pain, depression and anxiety and you can follow suit. It leads you to find help." (Stakeholder 7)

Today we’re hosting a webinar to share and discuss our research findings in more detail. For anyone who can’t make it, the webinar will be recorded and shared via the BoroManCan YouTube channel. Please get in touch if you’d like to know more about the campaign or the research; we’d be happy to share our final report once this is ready for publication. And watch this space for future blogs on this subject from our practice partners and peer researchers.


Below are links to support organisations relating to the issues raised in the post: 

Friday, 29 June 2018

Why we must stop using the F-word in relation to Gypsies & Travellers

Posted by Natalie Forster, Senior Research Assistant at Northumbria University and Fuse, and Helen Jones, CEO, Leeds Gypsy and Traveller Exchange

Fascination. Not the word you expected? Then read on to find out why we find it so problematic when people say they are ‘fascinated by’ Gypsy and Traveller Communities.

We frequently hear ‘fascination’ cited as a motivation for
 working with Traveller Communities by practitioners
There is certainly a captivation with Traveller Community ‘lifestyles’ in society. The numerous Gypsy and Traveller autobiographies and television programmes devoted to Traveller Communities (perhaps best exemplified by the Channel 4 ‘Big Fat Gypsy Weddings’ phenomenon) have led Gypsy and Traveller life to be described as a ‘bestseller’, with little sign that this interest is fading. Television programmes are often badged as an exposé on Traveller Community lives, starting with the premise that Traveller Communities are hidden, closed-off and exotic. The Channel 4 Big Fat Gypsy Weddings series for example, promises a ‘Revealing documentary series that offers a window into the secretive, extravagant and surprising world of Gypsies and Travellers in Britain today’ (emphasis added). This language is not value free, and seems to foster a sense of intrigue or fascination in order to appeal to viewers.

Traveller Community members have a lack of opportunities to shape their own image in popular culture. A complete absence of Gypsies or Travellers among the proposed cast for an upcoming BBC Film adaption of Mikey Walsh’s memoir ‘Gypsy Boy’ recently drew attention to the exclusion of Traveller Community voices in the film industry. The understandable reluctance of many Gypsy and Traveller Community members to disclose their ethnicity for fear of racism and discrimination also means there are a lack of images or stories to counter the negative stereotypes peddled within mainstream media. That said, younger Traveller Community activists in particular are increasingly making use of forums through which they can challenge these portrayals.

What though are the implications of this issue for health practitioners, researchers and the public? Of course, we recognise that many of our colleagues share our aversion to programmes such as Big Fat Gypsy Weddings and the hugely problematic representations of communities that these advance. Yet, the underpinning premise of these shows remain unchallenged by many, and we frequently hear ‘fascination’ cited as a motivation for working with Traveller Communities by practitioners.

Why do we feel uncomfortable when someone says they are ‘fascinated by’ Traveller Communities? The use of ‘fascination’ echoes the voyeuristic sentiment of many television programmes and reinforces notions of Traveller Community members as exotic and worthy of special attention or interest. When mentioning working with Traveller Communities, the very reference to these groups often appears to prompt greater interest, but why should this be the case?

It is problematic, we think, in its divisiveness; in the impression it gives of Traveller Communities as mysterious and ‘other’, and a community that ‘outsiders’ can only look into. This downplays the possibilities for seeing commonalities between Traveller Communities and other sections of society – Gypsies and Travellers are seen less as people ‘like us’, facing similar experiences or challenges in life, and more as groups we should find out ‘about’ or gather information ‘on’.

A sense of fascination also seems to shift the motivation away from the interests of Gypsy and Traveller Communities themselves, and towards fulfilling the agenda of those working with these groups. A desire to satisfy one’s own curiosity about Traveller Communities can result in questions that are insensitive, such as those about the cost of someone’s caravan, or aspects of culture that are unconnected with the purpose of a visit.

It is for these reasons that we call for the reconsideration of the use of ‘fascination’ in relation to Traveller Communities and other groups who are seldom heard, as well as for greater questioning of the assumptions that lie behind this term, and the interests it truly serves.


Image: "Seeing My World Through a Keyhole" (4592429363_292aec80c9_z) by Kate Ter Haar via Flickr.com, copyright © 2010: https://www.flickr.com/photos/katerha/4592429363