Thursday, 18 September 2014

52 weeks in public health research, part 37

Posted by Jean Adams

The seminar room and cafe in our building are often used for small conferences by groups from around the university. I snapped this at about 7pm in the evening when one such meeting had well and truly turned the corner from conference to social. We never have beer, tobacco and biscuits at public health meetings. Honest.

This is the 'famine wall' on Beinn Dearg near Ullapool. This part of it is more than 1000m above sea level. It runs for many miles and is more than 8ft wide and 8ft high in places. It was constructed in the 1840s by farmers whose harvest had failed in return for money, or food. There are remnants of many of these 'make work' projects all over the north of Scotland (and I presume Ireland too). It would have been considered unseemly just to give starving people money (as per the modern welfare state). Instead, humanitarian landlords thought up projects such as these to keep their tenants occupied and fed. You can see that it was a beautiful day when we were there, although you can't see the chilling winds strong enough to knock us over at times. The conditions up there are likely to be dreadful more often than not. Despite the problems with the current welfare state, I still think it's better than having people build useless walls at 3000ft in Scottish mountain weather.

I took this picture of lemon cake at afternoon tea time at the recent meeting of the World Public Health Nutrition Association. I was fully intending of making the usual comment about the ironic placement of unhealthy food at a public health nutrition meeting. Turns out most of is was left at the end of the tea break.

This is an interesting development that I noticed at a petrol station recently. It was quite a substantial promotion on Coke Life - sweetened with stevia and with about two-thirds of the calories of red Coke. There's an interesting discussion of the 'natural' and 'low(er) calorie' claim here. Personally, I think two-thirds of the calories of red Coke, is still a lot of calories.

------------------
Just to remind you:

Each Thursday of 2014 we’ll try and post around four pictures on the Fuse blog that capture our weeks in public health research, from the awe-inspiring to the everyday and mundane. Given that more of the latter than the former exists in my life, I foresee problems compiling 208 images worth posting on my own. So this is going to have to be a group project. Send me an image (or images) with a sentence or two describing what aspect of your week in public health research they sum up and I’ll post them as soon as I can. You don’t have to send four together – we can mix and match images from different people in the same week.

Normal rules apply: images you made yourself are best; if you use someone else’s image please check you’re allowed to first; if anyone’s identifiable in an image, make sure they’re happy for it to be posted; nothing rude; nothing that breaks research confidentiality etc.

Tuesday, 16 September 2014

Haste ye back?

Posted by David J Hunter, Professor of Health Policy and Management, Durham University and Fuse Deputy Director

Many in the North East will be wondering how their region will fare if Scotland decides to go its own way on Thursday.

Some may be heard to say: ‘if you’re going can we come with you’?  Others might sullenly fear the worst, with our region caught between a hungry new nation impatient to prosper and chart a different course on the one hand, and an England which seems captive to the huge suction pump that is London hoovering up all before it and drawing in talent and resources from across the UK – or what was the UK.   

Where might health policy figure in the scheme of things post-referendum?  Will it fare better under independence? Or will things remain much the same or possibly deteriorate?

Financially, the Scottish NHS has always fared better than its English counterpart, enjoying higher per capita funding.  But spending on health services is not the only factor affecting health status.  Despite the extra funding, Scotland’s health remains stubbornly poor and generally inferior with higher mortality – hence the label the ‘sick man of Europe’.

Of course, with less funding for health care it might be worse.  But it’s more complicated than that. 
Perhaps liberated from the shackles and centralising tendencies of the UK (or London to be more precise), Scotland will be able to restore the public realm or invest in ways which will demonstrate that an austerity economic model can be replaced by a social model of development.

We know from Marmot’s work and WHO’s health strategy for Europe, Health 2020, that tackling the social determinants of health demands a whole of government and whole of society approach. 

Being able to achieve such joined up thinking and work across a whole system is much easier (in theory at least) in a small country.  And there are certainly signs that Scotland wants to be innovative and tackle health differently with its recently departed Chief Medical Officer, Harry Burns, extolling the virtues of asset based approaches and talking about wellness rather than ill-health.           

The Scottish government has been something of a cheerleader in public health policy having been quick to follow Ireland’s lead on banning smoking in public places long before England.

More recently, it took the lead in introducing a minimum unit price for alcohol although whether the policy will survive the EU single market rules remains to be seen. But where England dithers, Scotland appears willing to take bold action.

The real issue is whether an independent Scotland can do more to improve health and tackle inequalities than it can under current devolved freedoms and from others to come which are promised following a No vote.  

The answer is complicated.  After all, what does independence actually mean in our global world where paradoxically everything is interdependent at a time when nations and regions seek greater freedoms.  Are these opposing forces reconcilable?   Or will independence prove to be a chimera with Scotland even less able to realise its social justice aspirations?

Those voting with their heads will endeavour to weigh up the pros and cons and bring evidence to bear on their decision-making.

Those ruled by their hearts will not be swayed by an evidence base which is fiercely contested and offers no definitive answers.  They will be tempted to take the risk believing they have nothing to lose with the status quo and retention of a 300 year old Act of Union holding little appeal. 

But will the politics and the policies be so different in the end or just their packaging and presentation?   Can an independent Scottish government shake off the neoliberal embrace to which all governments since, and including, Thatcher have been enthral? 

In a global economy, no country is an island and to keep at bay, never mind hold to account, the rapacious transnational conglomerates, including the big consultancies and ‘advisers’ and lobbyists that are busy hollowing out the public realm in England, demands both vigilance and political courage of a kind that will tax the most socially enlightened politician.  

This is the true nature of the experiment underway in Scotland regardless of whether it achieves formal independence after the referendum or some form of ‘devo max’.

Can Scotland break with the Anglo-Saxon tradition and replace it with an ethos marked by collectivism, reciprocity and a commitment to public services? 

Or will it buckle under the pressures of global capitalism and dance to its tune?                

Yes or No, Scotland promises to be a fascinating laboratory for years to come for health policy-watchers.

Thursday, 11 September 2014

52 weeks in public health research, part 36

Posted by Simon Howard and Jean Adams

From Simon Howard: after the photo of the Messi Pepsi can, I thought this one I took on holiday in Naples took the biscuit - the Napoli football team as tins containing chocolate chip cookies! Judging from the end product, I'm not sure they thought too hard about the aesthetics, let alone what the public health consequences might be!

From Jean Adams: In October we are moving to Cambridge and we've been using our East Coast rewards points to house hunt in style. But all that time spent searching property websites during the week means that we are making use of the peace and space of first class to catch up on work.

From Jean Adams: I was in London earlier in the summer at one of those meetings that looks like you are being invited to contribute your expertise, but is actually someone very politely asking you to stop making so much fuss. The meeting ended early and I took the opportunity to visit the V&A's Disobedient Objects exhibit before my train. This Nicholas Klein quote made me feel just a little alone and ignored.

From Jean Adams: the 'big move' means that I have finally had to find the time to clear out my desk and cupboard. After ten years of not looking at any of them once, I am parting with my PhD notes. Both a little bit gut wrenching and a little bit liberating.

------------------
Just to remind you:

Each Thursday of 2014 we’ll try and post around four pictures on the Fuse blog that capture our weeks in public health research, from the awe-inspiring to the everyday and mundane. Given that more of the latter than the former exists in my life, I foresee problems compiling 208 images worth posting on my own. So this is going to have to be a group project. Send me an image (or images) with a sentence or two describing what aspect of your week in public health research they sum up and I’ll post them as soon as I can. You don’t have to send four together – we can mix and match images from different people in the same week.

Normal rules apply: images you made yourself are best; if you use someone else’s image please check you’re allowed to first; if anyone’s identifiable in an image, make sure they’re happy for it to be posted; nothing rude; nothing that breaks research confidentiality etc.

Tuesday, 9 September 2014

You can't ever win

Posted by Jean Adams

Brian McNeil sings a song called Sell you labour not your soul. The chorus goes: “Young and old, true and bold/ Sell your labour not your soul/ Solidarity's your goal - join the union”. It invariably involves a lot of audience foot stamping and fist waving.

I was reminded of this song during a conversation with my ‘leadership mentor’ a few months ago. NIHR sent a guy up to Newcastle to watch me at work, feedback on my leadership style, and discuss my career direction with me. My mentor had worked with lots of people funded by NIHR, so when he asked which UK academics I really wanted to be like, he knew the names I reeled off. “If you want to be like them,” he said, “you’re going to have to work more hours”. Then he laughed at me when I told him the university already got enough of my soul and said, “well you know the old saying: ‘if you’re not a socialist by the time you’re 20, you haven’t a heart; if you’re still one by the time you’re 40, you haven’t a brain’”. I still have a few years left to make the full transition.

All the images on work:life balance were cheesy. But I thought you'd be impressed by this photo of Brian McNeill playing the double-kneck bouzouki
There are people at the university that I strongly feel don’t get paid enough to work more than their contracted hours. But that’s not me – I get paid plenty well enough. And it’s not that I don’t feel passionate about (most of) what I do, or find myself enjoying thinking about it when I’m running or climbing hills, or sometimes get so engrossed in it that I’m still at my desk way past home time. I just think there should be more to life than work. That my life, and work, are both better for there being more to life than work.

I know there are many, many people working in public health research (and in lots of other areas) who work more than their contracted hours. In fact, my contract is a little vague about what my ‘contracted hours’ might be. Sometimes it seems like working all the time is the only way to be successful – somehow ‘good’ means ‘lots’. There seems no way to do everything that you want, or have, to do without working all the hours.

Academia is inherently a competitive venture. There is no absolute benchmark of good enough – it’s only ever relative to what other people manage. When one person starts churning out twice as much as anyone else by working longer and longer hours, it puts pressure on the rest of us to do the same. To keep up. Before you know it, you feel guilty every Sunday afternoon you don’t spend at your laptop.

But I have also come across well respected, and undoubtedly successful, academics who tell me how important it is to them not to start work before 8.30am, and not to leave the office after 6pm. Not just because it makes their lives better, but because this is the role model they want to be to those around them. These are not people who are doing sneaky work at home that they don’t let on about. They just seem to be focused in what they agree to do, to do it efficiently, and then to go home and do something else.

It is this type of person that I really want to be like. For me, the challenge is the focus and efficiency, not finding the energy to stay at my desk until midnight – although I would also struggle with that. Every Sunday afternoon that I spend at my laptop I feel that I have failed. I promise myself that next week I will focus more and be more efficient. I list the ways that I waste time and the things I should never have agreed to do. Instead of feeling guilty when I’m not working, I feel guilty when I am.

You can’t ever win.

Thursday, 4 September 2014

52 weeks in public health research, part 35

Posted by Martin White

Editor's note: Yes, it is possible that we skipped 4 weeks of this project. But I'm making the rules and I say that's okay. 

I am attending a national research leaders course funded by NIHR and hosted by Ashridge Business School in Hertfordshire periodically during this year and some of next. The course itself is very good (the role play on 'difficult conversations' was particularly educational), as is getting to know the class and faculty (some extraordinary people at the top of their game), and the food (!). But the venue and its setting, dating from the 14th century in parts, in the custodianship of the National Trust, is quite special. It feels like a real privilege to spend a few days once a quarter in these surroundings.

During the World Cup it seemed like everyone jumped on the marketing opportunity bandwagon. I'm not sure whether Krispy Kreme was indulging in this opportunity (the picture was taken during the tournament), or whether this marketing at a service station off the A9 in Scotland was aimed at travelling football fans or teams. Whatever, they clearly know how to sell more than one doughnut at once. These babies weigh in at an average of 363 calories (kcal) each (equivalent to 418 kcal/100g), so the exhortation to 'share' these with your team mates might not be such a bad idea.

This Playground Code is probably familiar to many of you as parents, and perhaps as children. I saw it when attending a ceilidh in a school hall to celebrate a very special birthday. I thought we could substitute 'work' for 'play' and, with a little further adaptation, make the world a better place. Just saying...

I seem to be travelling to London a lot more than I used to. I thought I had it all down to a fine art - leaving home 20 mins before my 07.11 train departs from Morpeth Station. I had not reckoned on some of our local farmers herding their sheep into the yard at this time of the morning. Fortunately, I made the train, which was a couple of minutes late.


------------------
Just to remind you:

Each Thursday of 2014 we’ll try and post around four pictures on the Fuse blog that capture our weeks in public health research, from the awe-inspiring to the everyday and mundane. Given that more of the latter than the former exists in my life, I foresee problems compiling 208 images worth posting on my own. So this is going to have to be a group project. Send me an image (or images) with a sentence or two describing what aspect of your week in public health research they sum up and I’ll post them as soon as I can. You don’t have to send four together – we can mix and match images from different people in the same week.

Normal rules apply: images you made yourself are best; if you use someone else’s image please check you’re allowed to first; if anyone’s identifiable in an image, make sure they’re happy for it to be posted; nothing rude; nothing that breaks research confidentiality etc.

Tuesday, 2 September 2014

What's happened to your local?

Posted by Mark McGivern, Specialty Registrar in Public Health, Balance

[Editor's note: this post was first published by Balance. Thanks for letting us repost it here.]

I was recently undertaking some research on behalf of Balance into the volume of alcohol promotions in supermarkets. Whilst doing this that I stumbled upon another interesting area which led me to do some further investigative work into the locations of some of these shops.

The Turnpike in Westerhope, before and after
My original research involved visiting 48 of the 90 convenience stores operated by Tesco and Sainsbury’s across the region. As I was going from store to store I realised that many appeared to be buildings that, in previous lives, were once pubs. It was apparent just by looking at some of these shops that they used to be pubs but others weren’t quite as easy to spot due to extensive renovation work and extensions being added to the original building.

My interest was already piqued and so I decided to take to the computer to do some online investigation. By locating each site on Google maps and looking at historic photographs my suspicions were confirmed at seven of the stores I visited. While that may only be around 15%, I’m certain that number would grow if I were to visit the remainder of the 90 stores in the region.

The seven stores I identified as converted pubs were:

• The Honeysuckle, Coatsworth Road, Gateshead - now a Tesco Express

• The Broadway, North Shields - now a Sainsbury’s Local

• The Turnpike, Westerhope - now a Tesco Express

• The Black Horse Inn, Windy Nook - now a Tesco Express

• The Station Hotel, Seaton Carew - now a Sainsbury’s Local

• The Lodge, Neville’s Cross - now a Sainsbury’s Local

• The Black Swan, Morpeth - now a Sainsbury’s Local

The Black Swan in Morpeth, before and after
It feels strange, as a member of the public health community, to be advocating to save pubs. However, this is a wider problem, with two key issues. Firstly, communities need to feel like they are being listened to when it comes to decisions being made in their villages, towns and cities. Secondly, it’s about the fact that supermarkets make cheap booze more readily available, increasing competition and making it difficult for small community pubs to compete. 

Pubs used to be not just a place for drinking, but for socialising with friends and family. In terms of local history, some of them also used to be impressive local buildings too, which have now been anonymised by the standard, uniformity of the supermarkets branding.

It’s no secret that community pubs up and down the country have suffered in recent times, but this latest trend has resulted in questions being asked of the current law which allows supermarkets to convert pubs without the need to apply for a change of use.

With such loose laws around these types of premises it’s no surprise that former pubs – that were likely once hubs of their communities – are seen as such appealing opportunities for supermarket giants.

CAMRA (Campaign for Real Ale) has spoken out against the loophole and called on government to amend the law so communities can have a greater say in whether local pubs can be converted into these types of convenience stores.

Labour appeared to have listened to these calls and earlier this year shadow small business minister, Toby Perkins, said he wanted to see local authorities and communities involved in the decision making process over planning decisions that centre around pub conversions.

These types of discussions can only be a good thing. It’s important for the issue of local decision making to be addressed at a high level, particularly with party conference season on the horizon and an upcoming general election. However, it’s also important to link it to the wider issues around price and availability of alcohol, particularly the cheap, strong alcohol. Alcohol is 61% more affordable today than it was in 1980 and measures such as minimum unit pricing would not affect sales or prices within local pubs, but would save lives, reduce crime and help cut the £21 billion that alcohol misuse costs the UK each year.

I’m sure there will be many more instances of pubs being converted into convenience stores throughout the region that I haven’t picked up on. If you’re aware of any then next time you’re out and about take a picture of the shop in question and send it to us with details of the location to info@balancenortheast.co.uk or tweet it to @BalanceNE.

Thursday, 31 July 2014

Holidays!

Is it holidays yet? Oh thank goodness.

The blog has spent the last few weeks hanging on to every scrap of work-related motivation it can find for dear life. It seems like everyone apart from the blog is on holiday. Facebook is full of holiday snaps. Twitter is packed with advice from Public Health England on how to cope with hot weather. But the blog has been diligently heading into work every day, ploughing through the to-do list, keeping the in-box under control.

But now it's holiday time!

The blog has a couple of friends who've rented a flat near Chamonix for the summer and the blog's off to join them for a month of rock, glaciers, ropes, crampons, snow in summer, and painstaking deciphering of French weather forecasts.

See you in September.

Photo by Matthieu Lienart

Tuesday, 29 July 2014

52 weeks in public health research: part 30

Posted by Amelia Lake, Martin White and Jean Adams

From Amelia Lake: My messy desk as I try to analyse data from our NIHR food environment project. Some tidying required!

From Martin White: I recently stayed at the Royal College of General Practitioners where the NIHR Public Health Research Funding Board held its June meeting. It has rather swanky hotel accommodation with well appointed meeting rooms, but what I liked most was the sympathetic architectural treatment, bringing together old and new, with light and airy atria and retention of period details. So much nicer than a drab hotel chain - indeed positively uplifting. I wonder if it affected our decisions? Now there's a study that needs doing...

From Martin White: The most recent Fuse Quarterly Research Meeting was held at the National Glass Centre, which is now owned and managed by Sunderland University. Offering a range of exhibits on the history of glass and examples of glass as art, the centre also boasts some excellent meeting rooms and a huge and airy café/restaurant - with glass on three sides (yes, more great architecture). This photo shows an exhibit in a show case on a galleried walkaway above the café. Outside the huge windows the river Wear is reflected in a curved mirror backdrop. I think we'll be using this venue again...

From Jean Adams: Arty shot of my academic gown and hood. There are a few tasks that academics are required to do that took my a little by surprise. One was that we 'must' take part in the academic processions that occur at all graduation ceremonies. There are about 20 academics at each ceremony, so if everyone is nice and takes their turn, each person only has to do this once every couple of years. The first few times I was bored. This year I attended one of the MBBS congregations. A few of my tutees and other students who have worked with me were graduating. Sir Paul Nurse was awarded an honorary doctorate and gave a great acceptance speech. His advice to the new graduates: don't loose your curiosity, your passion, or your sense of humour. The university's chancellor, Sir Liam Donaldson, spoke about the advances in medicine (nicely expressed in epidemiological terms), he has seen in his career and encouraged the graduates to go forth and advance the field some more. It turned out to be an uplifting 90 minutes away from my desk to reflect on why we do science, medicine, and teaching and how to keep doing it well.

------------------
Just to remind you:

Each Thursday of 2014 we’ll try and post around four pictures on the Fuse blog that capture our weeks in public health research, from the awe-inspiring to the everyday and mundane. Given that more of the latter than the former exists in my life, I foresee problems compiling 208 images worth posting on my own. So this is going to have to be a group project. Send me an image (or images) with a sentence or two describing what aspect of your week in public health research they sum up and I’ll post them as soon as I can. You don’t have to send four together – we can mix and match images from different people in the same week.

Normal rules apply: images you made yourself are best; if you use someone else’s image please check you’re allowed to first; if anyone’s identifiable in an image, make sure they’re happy for it to be posted; nothing rude; nothing that breaks research confidentiality etc.

Thursday, 24 July 2014

52 weeks in public health research: part 29

Posted by Jemma Hawkins, Jenni Remnant, Shelina Visram and Emily Henderson

From Jemma Hawkins (photo credit: Natalie Richards): When compiling the promotional material for a seminar we are organising on 'Tackling Workplace Sedentary Behaviour' we decided that it would be better to create our own image rather than using a stock one. One quick tidy of a colleague's stand-up desk, another colleague's smartphone and me as 'model' donning the famous DECIPHer t-shirt and hey presto!

From Jenni Remnant: Sat down to eat at a Knowledge Exchange conference last week run by the LSE and this was on the table.

From Shelina Visram: This picture was taken in County Durham after a meeting to discuss a pilot project on supporting lifestyle changes amongst people newly diagnosed with a chronic condition. I recently ran some focus groups in the community centre across the road, which required several telephone conversations with a local caterer about what I meant by a ‘healthy buffet lunch’. Thankfully their salad did not contain lard.

From Emily Henderson: It *might* have been said once or twice in the history books that academics are *sometimes* overworked and underpaid, but there are definite benefits. In June I had the pleasure of attending the EvaluatingComplex Public Health Interventions short course at DECIPHer. We were off the leash in the evenings, and I got very lucky with the weather! An evening picnic in Sofia Gardens along the river Taff, Cardiff, Wales. With the latest addition of 'The Lady' mag, white wine and cheeses.

------------------
Just to remind you:

Each Thursday of 2014 we’ll try and post around four pictures on the Fuse blog that capture our weeks in public health research, from the awe-inspiring to the everyday and mundane. Given that more of the latter than the former exists in my life, I foresee problems compiling 208 images worth posting on my own. So this is going to have to be a group project. Send me an image (or images) with a sentence or two describing what aspect of your week in public health research they sum up and I’ll post them as soon as I can. You don’t have to send four together – we can mix and match images from different people in the same week.

Normal rules apply: images you made yourself are best; if you use someone else’s image please check you’re allowed to first; if anyone’s identifiable in an image, make sure they’re happy for it to be posted; nothing rude; nothing that breaks research confidentiality etc.

Tuesday, 22 July 2014

Knowledge exchange

Posted by Jenni Remnant

Last week I went to a residential in Birmingham run by the London School of Economics. The theme for discussion and workshops was ‘Knowledge Exchange (KE) and Impact’, and had a focus based in social care and social work.

In terms of public health, impact is arguably a necessity and not something to tap on a grant proposal as an add-on. I would suggest that there is no point to public health research if the health of the public is not impacted upon (positively).

So as part of this residential we discussed stakeholder focus groups, partner organisations and dissemination. We discussed REF, academic and policy impact.


We discussed all the snazzy ways to tart up our findings and pitch them to people in an accessible way. These included videos, infographics, twitter and blogs amongst other things. We also learnt how to engage with journalists and the press.


And then on the last day, we learnt about the #JusticeForLB campaign – an incredible shout of anger that grew and was cultivated through Twitter. The campaign, started by the Mother of a young dude called Connor Sparrowhawk, has gained amazing momentum – and for me, personally, is many of the things KE and impact should be.

For a start – it was born from a real issue, as identified by people involved in the real issue.

Connor Sparrowhawk was in a specialist unit called Slade House, an NHS assessment and treatment unit in Oxfordshire. He had autism and epilepsy. Connor was in the unit for 107 days before he died by drowning in one of the baths. The cause of death was initially recorded as ‘natural causes’.

Secondly – the real issue was focused within and around the people it directly affected, and may directly affect in the future. The academics that did become involved in this became involved because it was clear something needed to change, and they cared.

Thirdly – it had, and has, impact: immediate tangible impact; demand from the Sparrowhawk family and support from the campaign meant that the death was subsequently found to be preventable, the unit has been closed down and there has been an inquest.

Finally – this campaign reached out; there were blogs, activities, sponsorships and endless tweeting.

Totally amazing and inspiring.

This might seem really far removed from what we do as researchers, but there is a pattern there that is not so different from what we do;

1) Identify an issue that needs further scrutiny
2) Scrutinise it.
3) Work out what it means, or what the implications are, and then
4) Work out recommendations to go forward with

The reason the #JusticeForLB campaign did such a spectacular job in doing this is in part, I think, due to the lack of any academic-type goals and limitations placed around it. REF was unimportant; impact ratings, finding a niche and career progression were not foregrounded. There was no traditional model to adhere to.

I’m aware that this story has a strong narrative, with irrefutable social justice at the heart of it that may capture interest in a way that some public health doesn’t – but it doesn’t (or shouldn’t) hurt to occasionally think outside the box with research. Even if that box is in another box.

It would be cool to see more research instigated by, committed to and partnered with the people affected by whatever the issue it is. It seems a bit counterproductive to take an issue, decontextualize it through research, and then struggle to communicate the findings back to the ‘stakeholders’ at a later date. Especially if we are then going to lament how people haven’t enacted the lifestyle/policy/ [insert other] change advised in the research.

As useless as ever, I don’t really know how to implement changes that involve remodelling the academic research model – but the residential was definitely an excellent place to broaden the horizon.

I do hope to organise an unconference in the not so distant future though, as a start…so watch this space I guess!


Definitely check #JusticeForLB out on twitter if you get the chance, and spend just over 4 minutes looking at their animation – gifted by an illustrator as part of the campaign – it’s exquisite.

Thursday, 17 July 2014

52 weeks in public health research, part 28


From Catt Turney: I've been thinking a lot recently about the role of place, space and environment in public health, and thought this smoking area at Paddington station was a nice example of a very simple space-related intervention. It's effectively a little cage around some chairs - the sign reads 'Smoking is only permitted in the area designated by barriers around this notice'. The station was busy but this area was completely deserted - a sign it's failing, or working as intended?
From Bronia Arnott: At Newcastle central train station to travel to Leeds for the UKCRC Public Health Research: Centres of Excellence Conference a couple of weeks ago to talk about developing interventions to promote active travel.

 
From Bronia Arnott: Being a parent can make you feel as if you are part of a government experiment that you never consented to at times. This week my daughter brought home this leaflet from school advertising the collaboration between Disney and Change4Life which you can read more about here. The idea is that by working together they will encourage children to increase their physical activity during the school summer holidays. As a developmental health psychologist I can't help but wonder if this intervention is being evaluated?

From Jean Adams: despite my Coke-marketing photo-obsession, my soft-drink of choice is in fact Diet Coke. So this can of Diet Pepsi was a novelty. Sometimes I wonder if people who put their name and face to junk food marketing campaigns think about the implications at all. Maybe Messi thought this was okay because it was Diet Pepsi and not the real thing (which I can understand, but might argue with). Or maybe he didn't think about it at all - it was just another photo shoot that his agent arranged for him.

-------------------

Just to remind you:

Each Thursday of 2014 we’ll try and post around four pictures on the Fuse blog that capture our weeks in public health research, from the awe-inspiring to the everyday and mundane. Given that more of the latter than the former exists in my life, I foresee problems compiling 208 images worth posting on my own. So this is going to have to be a group project. Send me an image (or images) with a sentence or two describing what aspect of your week in public health research they sum up and I’ll post them as soon as I can. You don’t have to send four together – we can mix and match images from different people in the same week.

Normal rules apply: images you made yourself are best; if you use someone else’s image please check you’re allowed to first; if anyone’s identifiable in an image, make sure they’re happy for it to be posted; nothing rude; nothing that breaks research confidentiality etc.

Tuesday, 15 July 2014

Fuse duck flies into the University of Northumbria

Posted by Barbara Harrington

Fuse Duck arrived at Northumbria University on 30th May for a few weeks with me, Barbara Harrington, a researcher and lecturer in public health and patient safety. He quickly settled in having a cup of tea with his new friend, Stress Penguin from Redcar. Stress Penguin was liberated from Redcar whilst doing some interviews around Healthwatch, looking at the role of the new patient and public involvement organisations in the North East.


By Tuesday 3rd June and a lot of switching between PDFs, Excel Files, SPSS and SurveyMonkey for a Delphi project, something stronger than tea was called for. Fortunately Lesley Geddes (in the background), a principal lecturer with a particular interest in health promotion, behaviour change, and social marketing for health, was on hand to provide corrective public health messages about responsible drinking.


On Wednesday, 4th June, Fuse Duck joined in the celebrations when copies of Reforming Healthcare appeared written by Profs Ian Greener, David J Hunter, Russell Mannion, Martin Powell - and me! This is a major critical overview of the research published on healthcare reform in England from 1990 onwards. As you can see, Fuse Duck is riveted, considering the implications of this research for current debates about healthcare reorganisation in England.


Also on Wednesday, Fuse Duck attended our theory discussion seminar - the highlight of the month for many research staff, PhD students and other academics months. Here, staff from different disciplines within the faculty read and discuss some of the key theoretical texts from the social sciences. The seminars are led by Mick Hill, Robbie Duschinky, and Ian Robson. So far we have looked at chapters from Foucault’s Psychiatric Power lecture series, and Bourdieu’s Misrecognition and Symbolic Violence. These are always well led and interesting, discussing theory in relation to the times they were written and how relevant they continue to be. 

In June, we discussed Goffman’s Presentation of Self – Chapter 1. As usual the discussion was wide ranging including references to Hamlet, as well as presentation of self in relation to higher education teaching and health, social work, and education practice. With Fuse Duck attending, there was also a discussion about whether he had inadvertently disrupted the expected setting and consequently the personal fronts people displayed in this seminar. It was in fact a very apt seminar for Fuse Duck to attend. Here he is Ian Watson and me getting to grips with some of the finer points of Goffman.



Thursday, 10 July 2014

52 weeks in public health research, part 27


From Catt Turney: Being in an office when the weather is glorious can be a bit grotty. Luckily, the healthy-snack opportunities posed by summer almost make up for having to be inside rather than frolicking in the sunshine.

From Catt Turney: We recently had an unofficial DECIPHer social climbing Pen y Fan, a little mountain in South Wales. This greeted us at the end - apparently, even up a mountain, you can't get away from the idea that it's only a fun day out if there's junk food or alcohol.

From Amelia Lake: my pass from my first high level steering group meeting for the food responsibility deal - watching policy in practice & the negotiations & complications of food policy.

From Bronia Arnott: I was at the Sage Gateshead with my daughter for a performance called "At the Seaside". It was aimed at young children and parents and involved singing and dancing along to seaside-related songs. I was very impressed that they even made up a song about the importance of sun protection! Hopefully the catchy, repetitive, action song meant that at least some of the children went home remembering the importance of 'slip, slop, slap, seek, slide' - slipping on a t-shirt, slopping on some suncream, slapping on a hat, seeking shade or shelter, and sliding on some sunnies! 

------------------

Just to remind you:

Each Thursday of 2014 we’ll try and post around four pictures on the Fuse blog that capture our weeks in public health research, from the awe-inspiring to the everyday and mundane. Given that more of the latter than the former exists in my life, I foresee problems compiling 208 images worth posting on my own. So this is going to have to be a group project. Send me an image (or images) with a sentence or two describing what aspect of your week in public health research they sum up and I’ll post them as soon as I can. You don’t have to send four together – we can mix and match images from different people in the same week.

Normal rules apply: images you made yourself are best; if you use someone else’s image please check you’re allowed to first; if anyone’s identifiable in an image, make sure they’re happy for it to be posted; nothing rude; nothing that breaks research confidentiality etc.

Tuesday, 8 July 2014

Social policy and public finance: Are possibilities for health equity shrinking?

Posted by Ted Schrecker, Professor of Global Health Policy, Durham University


With the publication of Thomas Piketty’s massive book Capital in the Twenty-First Century, the acceleration of economic inequality has belatedly begun to receive the attention it deserves. His is, in fact, just one of several indispensable recent treatments of the topic. Another, which has received less publicity, is Hard Times: The Divisive Toll of the Economic Slump, by Guardian editorial writer Tom Clark and sociologist Anthony Heath – a meticulously researched treatment of how the recession has affected the United States and the United Kingdom. Readers too impatient to read Capital’s elegantly written 655 pages can find a highly condensed summary of much of Piketty’s work in the 23 May 2014 issue of Science. The summary is especially valuable for a conclusion that comes through more emphatically than it does in the book: ‘Inequality does not follow a deterministic process. …. There are powerful forces pushing alternately in the direction of rising or shrinking inequality. Which one dominates depends on the institutions and policies that societies choose to adopt’.
This is not new to those of us concerned with the social determinants of health; consider the WHO Commission on the topic and its focus on ‘the inequitable distribution of power, money, and resources’. Against this background, what are we to think of a new report on The Condition of Britain from the Institute for Public Policy Research? Since it was released in the same week as initial findings from the Project on Social Exclusion indicating that the proportion of British households living with multiple forms of material deprivation has doubled in the past three decades, one might have expected recommendations for a frontal assault on the elements of economic inequality that are most destructive of health to be the centrepiece of the IPPR report.
Not so. Instead, we get prescriptions for a ‘richer version of equality [that] is more complex than one focused purely on the distribution of material resources’ (p. 16) and the priceless statement that: ‘Like many other countries, Britain has experienced an unwinding of the postwar compression of market inequalities, and its tax and benefit system has had to work increasingly hard to reduce disparities in wealth and income. Fiscal constraints will limit the scope for post-tax redistribution in the years ahead, while tendencies towards greater wealth inequality may intensify (Piketty, 2014)’. This goes on for almost three hundred pages.

Crisis, what crisis?
In a jurisdiction that taxes huge incomes and accumulations of wealth as lightly as the United Kingdom, talk of fiscal constraints and the limited scope for post-tax redistribution is, to put it politely, nonsense. I prefer a stronger term, but Fuse probably doesn’t. The imperative of eliminating the deficit cannot be ignored, but as George Monbiot recently pointed out, on the revenue side the options include financial transactions taxes, wealth taxes and ‘a progressively banded council tax’. The most straightforward option is a return to much higher marginal tax rates on the personal incomes of the ultra-wealthy, which were the norm in many countries until quite recently. Thomas Piketty and his long-time collaborator Emmanuel Saez have themselves suggested this. (All these observations are also relevant to the proliferation of nonsense about the crisis of financial sustainability supposedly facing the NHS, now being regurgitated even by people who should know better.) On the expenditure side, massive welfare programmes for the propertied and the arms traders like HS2 and Trident replacement could be rethought.  

None of this would matter much – the IPPR report could be dismissed as an uninformed and unfortunate reprise of the discredited Third Way – except that the report apparently will shape much of the Labour Party’s agenda for 2015, and if elected thereafter. In other words, it represents the current limit of permissible official discourse, what one might call the frontier of political possibility for reducing inequality, and the message is clear: too bad, it can’t be done.

A week is a long time in politics, and the location of the frontier could change – not least in response to spirited advocacy for considering public finance and its equity implications as a public health issue. In the absence of such change, Johan Mackenbach’s gloomy 2010 conclusion that ‘reducing health inequalities is currently beyond our means’ will turn out to have been spot-on. We must be very clear, in private and in public, about the implications: the best that can be hoped for is a reduction in the pace at which health inequalities are growing, and even that is uncertain. Harsh words, but the times demand them. To quote Bob Dylan, ‘let us not talk falsely now, because the hour is getting late’.

All views expressed are exclusively those of the author.

Thursday, 3 July 2014

52 weeks in public health research, part 26

Posted by Lynne Forrest and Jean Adams

So, week 26. That's half way. We haven't missed a week and there's been a full complement of four pictures each and every week. People, we are doing great. Only 26 weeks to go!

From Lynne Forrest: this is my family Saturday food shopping. I think it demonstrates the current confusion around healthy eating perfectly. The trolley contains fruit and muesli (good), fruit juice (used to be good but now the sugar is a concern), butter and cheese (used to be bad but fat is now potentially rehabilitated), as well as crisps, biscuits and pizza (definitely bad, and I'm clearly letting the public health side down here, but as they're from Marks and Spencer it's good quality bad food – does that make it any better?!)

From Jean Adams: My great uncle died recently. Although I'd never met him, I found myself tasked with finding his birth certificate in order to register his death. After looking absolutely everywhere else in his flat for it, I final flung open the kitchen cupboards in despair thinking maybe there was a secret stash of important documents under the bread. This is what greeted me: Morrison's saver's tinned soup, mushy peas, custard and fruit. I wasn't quite sure whether to laugh or cry. I finally found the birth certificate in a shared cupboard in the hallway of his apartment building.

From Jean Adams: Yeah, I didn't really find this funny. Yeah, I get that it's hilarious that 'pushy health types' like me don't even have a sense of humour. Yeah, I enjoyed a bag of crisps on the train with a cup of tea - what of it?

From Jean Adams: this supermarket convenience store isn't near a school. But this is some pretty heavy store-front alcohol marketing I'd say.

-------------------

Just to remind you:

Each Thursday of 2014 we’ll try and post around four pictures on the Fuse blog that capture our weeks in public health research, from the awe-inspiring to the everyday and mundane. Given that more of the latter than the former exists in my life, I foresee problems compiling 208 images worth posting on my own. So this is going to have to be a group project. Send me an image (or images) with a sentence or two describing what aspect of your week in public health research they sum up and I’ll post them as soon as I can. You don’t have to send four together – we can mix and match images from different people in the same week.

Normal rules apply: images you made yourself are best; if you use someone else’s image please check you’re allowed to first; if anyone’s identifiable in an image, make sure they’re happy for it to be posted; nothing rude; nothing that breaks research confidentiality etc.

Tuesday, 1 July 2014

Alcohol marketing at the school gates?

Posted by Mark McGivern, Specialty Registrar in Public Health, Balance

[Editor's note: this post describes a piece of work conducted by Mark and Balance. Just for the avoidance of doubt, we thought we should point out it hasn't been formally peer reviewed.]

I’m a reluctant supermarket shopper at the best of times. If possible we try and do most of our shopping online or using local shops or the market (at least, that’s my excuse for not having noticed the scale of alcohol displays in our supermarkets).

However, in the first week of working at Balance, the North East Alcohol Office, a colleague came back from a lunchtime visit to a supermarket, somewhat vexed at the labyrinth of alcohol displays they had walked through in the store.

This sparked an idea for a piece of work studying the promotion and provision of alcohol by our supermarkets, which we hope to publish in the near future.

The Government’s public health responsibility deal (PHRD) is a partnership between government, industry, academic and voluntary sector experts aimed at developing voluntary agreements to address specific public health objectives.

Within the PHRD, the five largest supermarkets (‘Top 5’- Tesco, Asda, Sainsbury’s, Morrisons. Co-Op) have made a series of pledges regarding alcohol, which including the following:

A6. We commit to further action on advertising and marketing, namely…. not putting alcohol adverts on outdoor poster sites within 100m of schools…..
There could obviously be some debate as to whether a self-imposed exclusion zone of 100m constitutes a responsible attitude towards alcohol promotion by supermarkets. In theory, I suppose it shows intent at the very least, but does it go far enough? If you take the guidance on planning applications for takeaways which recommends an exclusion zone from schools of 400m, then the alcohol advertising exclusion zone pales into insignificance by comparison.

Making this pledge is all very well, but there was also no mention of whether the Top 5 applied the same standards to their own store-front advertising as part of the pledge. I wanted to see whether it would be possible to demonstrate compliance with this pledge by visiting stores throughout the North East to look at the extent to which the Top 5 stuck to their pledging guns.

To look into this 100m exclusion zone further, I visited a number of stores across the region and, as part of the wider study, assessed the Top 5’s compliance with this pledge.

The 378 postcodes of the stores of the 5 major supermarket retailers were entered into a GIS system and mapped against all primary and secondary schools to identify those that were within 100m of a school. Initially, 18 primary schools and two secondary schools were identified as potentially being within 100m of a supermarket. This was narrowed down to 10, once inaccuracies in the postcode address file were accounted for.

So, ten stores were identified as being within 100m of schools. After visiting these, it became clear that a number appeared to be contravening the alcohol pledge. Three had on-site, outdoor alcohol advertisements. Another had an alcohol advert in a window that was intended to be visible outside.


Examples of storefront alcohol advertising within 100m of a school premises in the North East of England
Clearly, as with all advertising, there is a seasonal aspect to take into consideration. At the time of carrying out the research, it was close to Mother’s Day. Whilst most of the adverts related to non-alcohol related gifts & seasonal products, there were also a number of adverts promoting wine. For those with good eyesight, I should stress that I am not suggesting fabric softener is an appropriate mother’s day gift!

Perhaps, if the same stores were revisited now, during the World Cup, the likelihood of there being more adverts associated with alcohol consumption would be much higher too.

This research has highlighted that there may still be some way for the Top 5 (and retailers and manufacturers more broadly) to go when it comes to taking the Public Health Responsibility Deal seriously. After all, a pledge means nothing if it isn’t seen through. And if it isn’t seen through, then people lose confidence in it.

There have also been a number of other examples of alcohol advertising in the North East that wouldn’t meet with the responsibility deal pledges, like advertising alcohol at school bus stops for example.

Examples of alcohol advertising within 100m of a school premises in the North East of England
There is a body of evidence that suggests exposure of children and young people to alcohol advertising increases initiation of drinking and also encourages heavier drinking among existing drinkers. 

Advertising in such close proximity to schools is something that most major producers and retailers have committed not to do, but this limited investigation has shown otherwise.

These are unlikely to be isolated examples and we’d like to try and compile some more examples from across the North East, and beyond. We know elsewhere in the country there have been successful objections to such practises. Next time you take your kids to school, if you see any alcohol advertising at the school gates, please send us a picture with details of the location to: info@balancenortheast.co.uk or tweet it to @BalanceNE.

The debate about appropriate restrictions & guidelines on alcohol advertising will continue. However, if we don’t highlight the apparent lack of compliance by the retail and manufacturing sector with their current pledges, it may be assumed that the current controls are not only being observed, but are enough. By demonstrating that this isn’t the case and taking a stand on alcohol advertising, we can take a small, but significant step in the right direction.